A Comprehensive Discussion On The Similarities Of Change As Discussed In The Heart Of Change And Organizational Behavior And Management

2201 words - 9 pages

Introduction
A famous Greek philosopher, Heraclitus, once said “Change is the only constant.” That can be said of business too. “Business as usual” is no longer the world of the eight to five workday, Monday through Friday with the safety net of cornering the market place in the selected region. As Thomas Friedman’s bestselling book “The World is Flat” states due to globalization and advances in technology, “the world is on a level playing field, where all competitors around the globe have equal opportunity to compete,” in a global market that historically and geographical has been impossible several decades ago (Ref #1). In light of this, the authors of “The Heart of Change”, John Kotter and David Cohen (2002) and “Organizational Behavior and Management” textbook by Ivancevich, Konopaske, and Matteson, (2011) authored respective books on implementing effective change in an organization. While each book offer’s similar insights on change through organizational behavior, there are slight differences. One author provides insight through the use of case studies and opinions while the other relies on academic work through theories, research, and supporting evidence. In the paragraphs to follow, there will be a careful comparison between Kotter’s Eight Step Change Model for implementing change powerfully and successfully as outlined in the book, “The Heart of Change” to the textbook “Organizational Behavior and Management”, by Ivancevich, Konopaske, and Matteson, (2011).

Discussion
In a world of turbulence and fast moving players, companies must consistently act to change how they do business in order to stay ahead of the competition, or face the possibility of extinction. As Jack Welch said, “If the rate of change on the outside exceeds the rate of change on the inside, the end is near” (QUOTE). Executives and business leaders realize change is a must to maintain market share and capital. In the book “The Heart of Change” by Kotter, the author offers a radically different theory on how business must initiate change in their respective company; that is contrary to the natural instincts of business leaders and those described in the Organizational Behavior and Management textbook by Ivancevich, et al. Kotter argues that successful change is a “complex affair that happens in eight stages,” and must be meticulous in initiating a change (QUOTE). He argues, “good analysis rarely motivates people but it’s the real world examples that impact and influences their emotions” (Kotter, pg. 12). The eight stage flow states how effective change must take place in: Creating urgency, building a guiding coalition powerful enough to guide a company through change, developing a vision and strategies, effectively communicating the vision and urgency, empowering employees by confronting barriers and hindering change, creating ways to achieve “short-term wins” that create momentum, maintaining focus on the goal and keeping momentum going, and finally...

Find Another Essay On A Comprehensive Discussion on the Similarities of Change as discussed in The Heart of Change and Organizational Behavior and Management

Drivers of Organizational Change and the Keys to Successful Organizational Change

1534 words - 7 pages change – hindsight is certainly the best teacher. Case 2 and case 3 covers the two educational sector organizations that I had the privilege of working with in my recent career. Organizational change theorist (Newman, 2012) proposes a three-phase change management framework for creating sustainable change in a campus environment that helps simplify the complexities of implementing change in an educational environment. Drivers of Organizational

Organizational Change and Stress Management Essay

1385 words - 6 pages due consideration to human factors, there are times when the human side is accounted for in a token and instrumental way (Bovey & Hede, 2001). Change requires the participation of people who must first change themselves in order for organizational change to succeed (Evans, 1994; Bovey & Hede, 2001). It takes the employees of an organization and not management to ensure change will be successful. Focusing only on the management’s perspectives on

Significance of Organizational Change in Robbins' Awaken the Giant Within and Gladwell's What the Dog Saw

914 words - 4 pages agents need to develop – they need to learn that the delivery of a message is as important as its content. If you want to motivate a group to bring about a substantive organizational change you have to be sincere, act with the organization’s best interest at heart, listen well, use phasing and establish a sense of presence -- because all eyes will be on you. The symbolism of your actions and movements can enhance or destroy your message and intent.

What aspects of change are discussed in the texts you have studied this year?

2023 words - 8 pages and so he works tirelessly to earn money illegally and win Daisy back. Change is shown as being uncontrollable as Gatsby is a rational man who was self disciplined but his love for Daisy has made him disillusioned with money and as a result has earned his money illegally. Similarly, in the poem "The Door", the outcome of change is unpredictable as the repetition of the word "maybe" and "or" evoke a level of uncertainty: "Maybe a dog's rummaging

Critically analyze the role of senior managers as barriers to organizational change and explore how this can be addressed

2948 words - 12 pages obstructed. Too far from the front line is the last barrier from senior managers in the organizational change that will be discussed in this essay. Senior management is sometimes in danger of becoming disengaged from the nuts and bolts of the shop floor activity. Getting engaged in change from managers can be difficult if they see their role as distant from the processes being directly impacted. A few other reasons for senior managers being

Achilles as the Anti-Hero in Homer's "Iliad." Is Achilles' behavior justified, and does he change by the end of the story?

1125 words - 5 pages From beginning to end of Homer's The Iliad, Achilles is portrayed as a man stagnant in his ways. He is arrogant, impatient, unforgiving, vengeful, and extremely stubborn, and these awful attributes never cease. Achilles' lack of compassion perplexes the present situation involving the Achaens and the Trojans by making it difficult to figure out which side is truly good and evil--both sides have good reason to fight. Even though Achilles is set

The psychodynamics of organizational change in the work place

2168 words - 9 pages work of top teams", Journal of Management Development, Vol. 15 No. 2, pp. 52-66.Seel, R. (2000), "Culture and complexity: New insights into organisational change", Organizations & People, Vol. 7 No. 2, pp. 2-9.Owen, H. (1997), Open Space Technology: A User's Guide, Berrett-Koehler, San Francisco.Klein, M. (1977), "On identification", in Klein, M., Heimann, P. and Money-Kyrle, R. (Eds.), New Directions in Psychoanalysis: The Significance of

Organizational Change, Learning and Performance Management

751 words - 3 pages Organizational Change, Learning and Performance management Presently, organizations have become a complex phenomenon, which requires numerous functions and strategies to manage the human resources. In today’s world there is a great need for organizational change and learning from time to time because of increasing globalization and technological advances. Proper plans and policies should be framed for implementing organizational change (Allen

Target Canada: The Effect of Organizational Change

2335 words - 9 pages merchandise over the border into Canada, was another issue leading to the company’s ineffective plans. Having noticed early on that the extra costs of tax will lead to a price mark up on in store products, could have saved Target a lot of its trouble. Step 2 in Kotter’s 8-step process explains the importance of thought out decisions and the creation of putting together a specialized group of individuals to lead the change and start everything

Change Of Heart

871 words - 3 pages A Change of Heart "The Rat Trap" written by Selma Lagerlof is a short story about an old disheartened beggar and thief who is taken in and shown generosity by a young woman, her kindness changes his bitter attitude about life. The peddler is a man who has fallen upon misfortune and now resorts to selling rattraps, begging, and thievery. He is very pessimistic about the world around him and sees the world as merely a "rat trap"

Literature Review on Organizational Change and Mergers

2364 words - 10 pages organization, though, it can represent a threat to security or an opportunity to move forward for the people involved (Goodman, 2000). Organizational change research was quite common in the 1990s (Barry, 1997; Reichers, Wanus, & Austin, 1997; Robertson & Seneviratne, 1995; Fox & Amichai-Hamburger, 1993; Ford & Ford, 1995). While the literature on organizational change in the 1990s was “mostly about de-layering and downsizing middle layers of management and

Similar Essays

The Change Of Heart Essay

773 words - 4 pages Martin Luther King Jr.'s strategies were a success in order to gain the goals of “prohibition of discrimination in the workplace and in housing, equal rights, protection from violence, safety in the workplace, and wages that one can support him or herself on were unheard of demands at the time” (Johnson). Well, the goals Martin Luther King Jr. were not given because of his assassination in the year 1963 and the assassination of JFK stopped the

Ideas For Change. Above All, Leadership Ought To Be Identified, Taught And Discussed As A Function, Or Set Of Functions, Different From Management, Administration Or Command

941 words - 4 pages Ideas for ChangeI suggest the following positive changes aimed at producing a more comprehensive and effective Army leadership doctrine. Above all, leadership ought to be identified, taught and discussed as a function, or set of functions, different from management, administration or command. To provide the necessary conceptual framework the Army's doctrinal definition of leadership should be modified along the several lines. It should be

Evaluating Change And Management Of Organizational Change At A&B Smart Industries

1338 words - 5 pages to keep up with competition or to improve the whole system. Change is also caused by internal and external forces. Issues of Organizational change: Employee resistance: Resistance can be because the employees find the path of change flawed, which is a good as the change may actually be flawed. Management may discuss with employees to gather different prospective and more in-depth knowledge of change External or Internal Issues: Government

A Change Of Heart Essay

1042 words - 4 pages had changed physically but not mentally. I needed his smile to assure me of that. A calming feeling came over me as I walked through the revolving doors and out of the hospital into the bright sunshine. Removing the 200 pounds of iron that sat on my heart and leaving behind the massive building which housed the source of my troubles felt welcoming. I walked away from the situation knowing that my grandfather's personality or love for me did not change. However, my attitude shifted from looking at my grandfather as not being acceptable, to understanding that the only thing that had changed was his physical appearance; he was still the same.