A Critical Review On The Dust Bowl

698 words - 3 pages


The Dust Bowl, written by historian Donald Worster, is a true story about how North America’s Great Plains faced one of the worst man-made environmental disaster in world history. The book depicts the story of the Dust Bowl in ecological as well as human terms. Worster argues that there was in fact a close link between the Dust Bowl and the Depression, that the same society produced them both, and for similar reasons. Worster used plain residents and their experience of living in the plains during the Dust Bowl to give us a better incite on how capitalism mainly influenced the dust bowl.
This book focuses on the dust bowl and how capitalism was one of its many influences according to Worster. Capitalism is the central idea that an economic system in which trade, industry and the means of production are controlled by private owners with the goal of making profits in a market economy (Wikipedia). According to Worster this idea was based solely on three concepts: ...view middle of the document...

This was a problem, because like any other business there was a limit. There were only so many crops that could be planted into the soil. Due to the outstanding planting of crops the top layer of soil erodes. When the top layered erodes, everything is basically dust. The land is no longer worth harvesting. However, the government didn’t try to prevent the problem. They only gave the farmers money to try and assist them in any way possible. As expected this didn’t help the problem at all, it only made the problem worst.
Donald Worster, the author, received a Bachelor of Arts in 1963 and a Master of Arts in 1964 from the University of Kansas. He continued his education at Yale University, earning an M.Phil. in 1970 and a PhD. in 1971. Worster came to KU in 1989 to occupy the Hall Chair in American History, thus returning to his undergraduate institution and his home region. Throughout his career, Worster has written several historical works that utilize the idea of “nature”.
This book has both negative and positive aspects. The biggest negative aspect is that Worster constantly gave “simple meanings” of some of the topics he discussed in the book. Everyone doesn’t need things to be broken down especially if it is already a comprehensive subject. He introduced too many character throughout the book, some of which I considered to be very irrelevant. One good aspect include the pictures gave you some insight on what the dust bowl actually looked like and some of the affects after. The dust bowl is something that a lot of people never really studied or were interested in.. Worster took something that was so boring and made it into a very eye opening subject. People never look at the “bigger picture”. This sometimes take away from the potential the subject could have.
In conclusion, Worster does a good job of giving many reasons as to why the dust bowl was a man-made disaster instead of a natural disaster. He does a good job at telling us how the farming agriculture and capitalism played a major role in the dust bowl. I never would have imaged that dust bowl had so much more reasoning than it did. Worster gave a great argument and explanation on what he think caused the dust bowl and what others felt about the dust bowl as well.

Find Another Essay On A Critical Review on The Dust Bowl

Causes of The Dust Bowl Essay

1004 words - 4 pages role in the creation of the Dust Bowl as well. The misconceptions about the climate and the annual rainfall in the Great Plains first began in the nineteenth century when people first began to settle in the area. Many of these settlers believed that they would always get enough rain to grow healthy crops because they settled on the land during years with abnormally high amounts of rain. Another reason people believed that the land would always be

The Dust Bowl and Agriculture Essay

1362 words - 5 pages blizzard” (Documentary, 2014). Such a name was given due to the storm’s visibility as a large black cloud, which made it look evil and scary. Although the black blizzard is what some people call the dust storm, most will refer it as the dust bowl. The dust bowl has a long history for its impact on agriculture. Starting around the early 1930s, the dust storms were becoming visible in the middle region of the United States (Ganzel, 2003). This middle

Farmers in the Dust Bowl

1795 words - 8 pages country many of these farmers would be forced to give up their land. (Source 3 pg 130) The Dust Bowl took a massive toll on farmers across the nation mostly in the Great Plains region. The states that were the most afflicted by the Dust Bowl were Colorado, Kansas, Texas, Oklahoma, and New Mexico (Source 8.) The Dust Bowl itself officially began in 1931 with a series of severe droughts that lasted for seven years. (Source 1 pg 20.) In one single dust

What Caused The Dust Bowl?

2393 words - 10 pages soil for hundreds of miles, which could remain active for ten hours or more (Hansen, 667). The storms actually had the potential to drag on for days on end. In 1939, for example, one storm stop blowing for more than one hundred hours. The Dust Bowl impacted a large portion of the states; ranging from Colorado to Washington D.C. More than one million acres were affected all together. The heart of the dust storms concentrated on the Great Plains

The Dust Bowl: Farming in the 1930s

960 words - 4 pages families and neighbors came together. (Reinhardt n. pag.) There were many ways the people spent their time. They did lots of things like going to the movies, playing board games, or listening to the radio all for free.(Reinhardt n. pag.) in 1940 rain was better and the federal government programs had electricity going to the house to make life a lot easier (Reinhardt n. pag.) Can’t talk about farming without the dust bowl. There are many causes

The Drought: Surviving the Dust Bowl

4172 words - 17 pages somewhere else. They were the epitome of tough, courage beyond measure, because they lived on faith in God, hope and the three little words, “if it rained”. Therefore, this research will provide a glimpse of what life was like for the people of the Dust Bowl and their recovery during a period of American history known as, “The Dirty Thirties”. By learning about what the Dust Bowl was, the struggles of farming the land and surviving the hardest of

People Affected by the Dust Bowl

978 words - 4 pages n. pag.). While traveling through the midwest a reporter named Robert Geige, wrote, “Three little words achingly familiar on a western farmer’s tongue, rule life in the Dust Bowl of the continent- if it rains” (The Drought n. pag.). People back then used the term Dust Bowl to help describe the people that lived in the hard times of the drought stricken region during the Great Depression. The Dust Bowl is still a term we use today to describe the

The Cause and Effect of the Dust Bowl

869 words - 3 pages death and destruction, environmental damage, and economic loss. The enormous amount of dust coupled with the high winds created “choking storms” that suffocated people and livestock. This created the disease commonly known as “dust pneumonia,” which became a typical illness amongst the people of the affected areas. The deaths caused by the dust bowl accumulated up to about 7,000. Due to the scattered population throughout the region and

Okies and the Hardships of the Dust Bowl

1102 words - 4 pages The Dust Bowl was the name given to the Great Plains area in the 1930s. Much of the region was an agricultural area and relied on it for most of their economy. Combined with The Great Depression and the dust storms, farmers in the Great Plains area were severely hurt. These farmers were seeking opportunity elsewhere near the Pacific where they were mistreated by the others already there. The mistreatment is a form of disenfranchisement, by

The Dust Bowl: Could We Face It Again

1608 words - 6 pages Essay #2The Dust Bowl: Could We Face It AgainThe Dust Bowl was a very tragic event for many thousands of Americans. Many people in the Great Plains region were faced with some of the hardest challenges in their life. A lot of families were forced to leave their homes for some other place where they could find work because the barren land was unable to produce crops to support their farming lifestyles. Woody Guthrie sings, "On the fourteenth day

Desertification and Examples Such as The Dust Bowl

2362 words - 10 pages lifeline, once gone nothing but desert is left. With each passing the future looked bleaker and people started wondering if the Dust Bowl could be stopped or turning into an American Sahara. In May of 1934 a giant dust storm raced across the United States dumping millions of tons of soil in New York, Washington, Chicago, and Atlanta. Finally the government noticed that something is going on out west and that something must be done. Hugh Hammond

Similar Essays

Daniel Worster's Dust Bowl Review

1552 words - 7 pages The Dust Bowl of the 1930s was a massive and incessant "storm" which altered the way of life for the Depression ravaged citizens of America. The people awoke every morning hoping and praying for rain, while outside on their farms and in many urban areas, the conditions only worsened. Donald Worster's Dust Bowl, The Southern Plains in the 1930s, is an intricately detailed account of this storm which produced black blizzards and carried dust and

The Dust Bowl Essay

1663 words - 7 pages he reached his house, his father rushed him inside. The first of many dust storms hit and the period known as the Dust Bowl began. The Dust Bowl was a brutal time period in Midwestern history; farmers were pushed off their land and forced to find new homes in new states. On a website called Drought Disasters, sponsored by Browing University, it was written “the seeds of the Dust Bowl may have been sown during the early 1920s. However

The Dust Bowl Essay

1387 words - 6 pages . 230) The Dust Bowl, even more so than the Great Depression, became the dominant national symbol of bankruptcy and ecological decay-the irony is that it was the capitalistic values that our country holds so highly that ultimately facilitated both the creation of the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression. Worster's "Dust Bowl" is a very informative work that makes a great contribution to understanding the effects that a consumer society can have on

The Dust Bowl Dance Of A New Generation

1054 words - 5 pages more than forty percent of adults in America have a college degree according to the Washington Post. This pressure exerted on students leads to many people having degrees that never needed them, but now those people have debts to pay. The really nasty thing is, only certain majors make the money needed to pay off such debts. This Dust Bowl for graduates is especially hard on certain majors. With the changing times and economic slowness, it seems