Abusive Law Essay

818 words - 4 pages

It is truly disturbing to find new evidence of how the state is allowed to interfere with the natural rights of parents. Certainly, cases exist where children must be protected from abusive mothers and fathers, and we rely on the justice system to do just this. At the same time, this presents a dangerous opportunity; once the state is permitted to determine what is right for a child, the authority of the parents may be so weakened, they are separated from their children and not allowed to give the real care they so want to provide.
This is the heartbreaking case of the Pelletier family in West Hartford, Connecticut, and it is one Linda and Lou Pelletier have been fighting for ...view middle of the document...

The situation continues, and it is reported that Justiana sneaks notes to her parents when she can telling them that she is in pain. Just shockingly, there remains no evidence at all that Linda and Lou Pelletier did anything beyond attending to their daughter's sickness as advised by the doctors treating her from the start.
Among the more horrifying aspects of this story to me is how, in this day and age, a group of doctors are enabled to cut a child off from their parents' care when nothing points to abuse. Even if the Children's Hospital doctors are correct and Justiana has mental issues, the Pelletiers are guilty of nothing except being naturally suspicious of a diagnosis contrary to that given by their own doctors, and equally – and rightly – concerned that this diagnosis was made with no consultation. That the hospital would then call in state authority to take control of a sick young girl, and one who has made it clear that she wants to be with her family, is nothing short of appalling. Meanwhile, Justinia undergoes treatment for a mental illness not yet identified. She smiles only when her parents visit her, and she is very much an adolescent prisoner of the state.
Personally, I can imagine the outrage I would as her parent experience every single day; in my own family, I witnessed a cousin...

Find Another Essay On Abusive Law

How to Reduce the Rate of Domestic Violence

2320 words - 9 pages As professional athletes remind us on a weekly basis, domestic violence is a social problem which continues to plague the nation. Through stricter law enforcement, improved hospital reporting techniques, and nationwide education and counseling, this problem can be reduced. Domestic violence has many different names such as, family violence, battering, wife beating, and domestic abuse. All these terms refer to the same thing, abuse by

Child abuse Essay

572 words - 2 pages care giving.In fact, abusive parents often do not know they are abusive. Our culture has, for generations, used corporalpunishment as a means of controlling child behavior. Some parents think society places no restraint on suchtechniques. Many may recall the old saying, 'spare the rod and spoil the child.' It is not always clear what the limits are in efforts to get a child to behave.The best way to stop the child abuse and stop the abusive

Battered Woman Syndrome

1488 words - 6 pages receiving their sentencing/ punishments for killing their abusive spouse, an amendment was made to the Queensland Criminal Code in the year 2009. The Queensland Law Reform Commission (QLRC) conducted a review of the excuse of accident and the defence of provocation in the year 2008 and whilst not strictly within the boundaries of their terms of reference, the QLRC had regard to the limitations of existing defences for a person in a seriously abusive

Domestic Violence

1622 words - 6 pages , he said/she said cases, and numerous loop holes in the written law, there are criminals who will return to society un-rehabilitated seeking revenge or to target another to abuse.The judicial system is somewhat successful is locking away most abusive individuals. The judge sets the tone in the courtroom and makes critical decisions affecting the lives of the victim, perpetrator, and children. According to M. Straus, author of Physical Violence in

horse abusibe amd how to stop it part 2

1303 words - 6 pages legislative needed to pass a law to shut the plant down. The closing of the three plants brought out the opponents claims that the closing of the plants would increase the cases of abusive and that the plant closures would be inhumane. That claim had no merit as “EWA” had researched that claim immediately and in 2008, EWA concluded that there was not any measurable or reportable escalation in abusive cases towards the equine community. EWA did however

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Domestic Violence Laws in Australia

922 words - 4 pages Good morning Minister of the Families I am Juliet Faeamani and I will be your consultant for today. I will be outlining the aspects of the law of Domestic and family violence that has a flaw in society. I will be analysing the current laws, evaluating the effectiveness of the law, comparing these laws, making recommendations for changes in the law and justifying how the proposed changes adequately address the needs of the Australian society

Child Abuse an essay about the books"A Child Called It" and "The Lost Boy." written by David Pelzer

757 words - 3 pages reporting it. With this law the child being abused it more apt to get help because he or she is around those types of people every day. Therefore, with these types of laws children are safer then without them.After a child gets taken away from the abusive guardian he or she is put into a foster home. In a foster home the options include: returning the child to his/her birth parents; termination of parental rights (a formal legal procedure) to be

Domestic Violence: Let's Change the Future

1408 words - 6 pages on the rise in the U.S. and help stop this epidemic. Victims should seek therapy and get educated on how to manage battered woman syndrome and the physical abuse, which will help them from being drawn back into violent situations. Growing up in a very violent and dysfunctional household I used to ask myself, how can someone be so violent and abusive to someone they say they love and respect. We cannot learn violence without someone teaching

Verbal abuse

2369 words - 9 pages certain acts need to be considered abusive in order for them to be important enough be looked into deeper and taken into considerationfor research. Statistics and information on verbal abuse could only be found on studies pertaining to law enforcement and this was because it was not considered a crime, like physical abuse. It was sad to see the degree of this throughout the literature. The low volume of verbal abuse reports could also be

Gun Control

1145 words - 5 pages (“Constitutional Law”). An armed population is the last defense against an abusive government. In the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson said, “…That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government…” Jefferson continued, “…it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their

War on Immigration

908 words - 4 pages law as abusive and divisive, when the federal government’s arrogant lack of enforcement of immigration law is abusive, divisive, and illegal. Obama and Holder find it incredulous that American taxpayers, who pay an enormous toll in treasure and suffering from the illegal immigration problem, would be less than understanding of the federal government’s incessant refusal to enforce immigration laws and seal the border. Over 60 percent of Americans

Similar Essays

Pediatric Abusive Head Trauma Essay

1394 words - 6 pages often physicians may overlook that diagnosis as a possibility. Pediatricians must recognize and respond to pediatric abusive head trauma, no matter how subtle the signs may be, in order to prevent further neurological injury. The appropriate reports must be made to child welfare services and law enforcement in order to make arrangements for the future safety of the child and deal with the legal ramifications of the abuser. Outcome and Prognosis

Sexual Harrassment Fact V. Myth: An Explanation Regarding A Few Of The Sexual Harassment Case Laws

682 words - 3 pages " be put into layman's terms?Here's my attempt:Speech and/or conduct, of a sexually discriminatory nature, which was neither welcomed nor encouraged, committed by or permitted by a superior, which would be so offensive to a reasonable person as to create an abusive working environment and/or impair his/her job performance.Situation is not as dire as you've heardAccording to the American Justice, this is what the sexual harassment law states, under

The Adversities Of Evading An Abusive Relationship

2162 words - 9 pages The Adversities of Evading an Abusive Relationship A relationship provides refuge, love and trust between two partners but every relationship has flaws that can permanently taint the two individuals and their bond. A major conflict that occurs in many relationships is domestic abuse. It is the control that a partner in an intimate relationship, who is usually the male in a heterosexual relationship, tries to exert on the female with methods

Intimate Partner Violence: What Is It And How Can You Get Help?

1583 words - 7 pages Intimate Partner Violence: What is it and how can you get help? Abuse is any behavior that is used to control and subdue another person through the use and fear of physical, emotional, and sexual assaults. Intimate partner violence can come in many forms. I will discuss these further as well as treatment options and services that are available for individuals in these abusive relationships. Intimate Partner Violence Intimate partner