Citizens From France And The Netherlands Rejected The Constitutional Treaty In 2005 Referenda And Irish Citizens Rejected The Lisbon Treaty In A 2008

1209 words - 5 pages

There have always been controversies surrounding the treaties in the post-Maastricht era. Such practices did not pass by the Constitutional and Lisbon treaties. The rejection of these two treaties had a major political impact on Europe as a whole. 29th of May 2005, was a memorable day in the history of the European Union. That particular date is connected with the referendum in France, regarding the ratification of the Constitutional Treaty and most importantly with the ‘non’ votes that were louder than the ‘oui’ votes. The citizen’s voice clearly stated that further integration amongst member states shall not be perceived through the Constitutional Treaty. Furthermore, just two days later Dutch referendum also stated the same as French. These ‘non’(s) and ‘nee’(s) threw Europe into a constitutional crisis. Three years later, the Lisbon Treaty was about to change everything, a step closer to an ever-close union. The treaty was already ratified in number of countries. It was Ireland’s citizens turn to decide on that matter with a referendum. 12th of June 2008, was the very date that Irishmen said ‘no’ to the treaty. Both of those failures of the treaties sent shockwaves all over Europe. Number of articles and official barometer polls looked after the referendum to try to project the main reasons behind the rejections. Certain aspects of the implication that drove the French and Irish public to halt further integration between states, are more or the less the same. For example, aspects of lack of knowledge and understandment of the treaties due to their complexity, common nationalistic and political views, just to name a few, are fundamental ideas behind the ‘noes’. However, there are also significant differences in the implications deriving from the different political and social context in these two countries. This paper would therefore look at the reasons behind the rejections. Why did they happen, who did it and how they did it, are the main question that need to be answered in order to understand why both Constitutional and Lisbon treaties were not ratified from, respectively from France and Ireland.
On 29th of May, 2005, France held a referendum of whether to ratify the European Constitution or not. Later on the same day results were carried out, it was ‘no from the very heart of Europe’ (Duval, et. al. 2005). Just a month later post-referendum survey was carried out by Eurobarometer aiming at finding data on why and who voted ‘non’ (2005, p.14). It showed high turnout rate of 69.3% of all the voters of which 54.70% rejected, whereas 45.30% voted ‘oui’. Many authors of newspaper articles as well as the Eurobarometer has dealt with the reason behind the ‘non’, examining different political, economic, socio-demographic concerns . Amongst the most important political factors that influenced voters in the ballot room, according to Duval (et. al. 2005), were the strong Euro-skeptic campaign led by nationalists, extremists, communists, socialists...

Find Another Essay On Citizens from France and The Netherlands rejected the Constitutional Treaty in 2005 referenda and Irish citizens rejected the Lisbon treaty in a 2008

Equality of Citizens and Non-Citizens in the EU

2575 words - 10 pages residency directive in the early 1990s . Incorporation of all nationals of EU Member States into the freedom of movement was the result of the Treaty of Maastricht (1992). It introduced the notion of EU Citizenship which is held by any person having the nationality of one of the Member States. Articles 20 (2)a and 21 (1) TFEU and the Preamble (1) of the 2004/38 Directive on the right of citizens of the Union and their family members to move and

Citizens as Consumers: Modernism and Convenience in the Twentieth Century

1835 words - 8 pages Convenience and efficiency became the raison d’être of the twentieth century. As the burgeoning markets of industrialism led to the shopping markets of consumerism, Washington, D.C. and Paris, France were competing to be the newest and the most efficient. As the cities became more efficient, they also became more automated: both in their infrastructure and in their denizens. It’s the nature of a city to be a hive for large numbers of people

Jay's Treaty in the States

696 words - 3 pages the contents of the Jay Treaty which were: 1) Britain agreed to give up the fur posts in American territory, 2) Britain also agreed to submit to arbitration the questions of disputed boundaries, the damage done to American shipping, and the debts due to British merchants. Although the people did not like these terms, Washington supported them to prevent us from going to war. Washington made his first move by sending a delegate to England, and

The Explanation of Dualism and why it is Rejected by Science

711 words - 3 pages , unlike other material objects, we not only have solidity and consistency, but we also have a body and a mind. Dualism is closely associated with the philosophy of René Descartes, which holds the idea that the mind is a nonphysical substance. Descartes was able to clearly identify the mind with consciousness and self-awareness, and then was able to distinguish this from the brain as the seat of intelligence. Hence, he is known for being the first to formulate the mind–body problem in the form in which it exists in today’s world. Works Cited Hergenhahn , B. (2008). An inroduction to the history of psychology. (6th ed.). Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth.

Wilson and the Treaty of Versailles

664 words - 3 pages the treaty. In the beginning Wilson opposed demanding compensation from the Central Powers, then the Allied leaders convinced Wilson to put reparations on Germany. The reparations set upon Germany was $56 billion, however in the end they only paid $9 billion which was more than Germany could afford. John Maynard Keynes said that the treaty should not deprive Germany of all its belongings, Germany is still made up of human beings and they should

The Paris Peace Conference and Versailles Treaty

1510 words - 6 pages , Neuilly with Bulgaria and Serves with Turkey . Though the most renown treaty is the Versailles Treaty, because it dealt with Germany, who was generally seen as the driving force behind WWI. To understand the prospectives, emotions and desire for revenge against the Triple Alliance, and Germany in general, you have to know that a vast majority of Europe had been destroyed, decimated and that the number of casualties were in the millions. It is

Germany and the Treaty of Versailles

1439 words - 6 pages land that produced sources of raw materials. They even had to give up land they had previously won, like Alsace and Lorraine and because they destroyed France’s coal producing lands, they lost Saar and the coal it produced to France for 15 years. They were stripped down to virtually nothing and Germany was crippled as a nation. The Germans did not want to sign the treaty; as a matter of fact, they destroyed many of their ships to keep from

The Kyoto Treaty with endnotes and bibliography

2741 words - 11 pages have been coming from the already developed countries like the U.S. and Europe. China has already started to cut their emissions by shutting down useless and dangerous factories. Also, the forests in China tend to absorb much of the gases. Russia’s president could not decide if he liked what the treaty had to offer and would not take action after taking a lot of time to think about the treaty. The U.S. economy would be hit ridiculously hard

Treaty Of Westalphia and The Nation State

2008 words - 8 pages are "public", as stated by Heywood in his third feature of the state (Heywood 2007, p91). The State represents all persons- citizen or non citizens- that inhabit its geographic proximity. Thus it has to be portrayed as prioritizing and representing the interest of the public as opposed to acting as a self interested private individual. This impresses into the State a notion of independence even from internal forces giving it a neutral public

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization and Ukrain

1368 words - 6 pages dominant interest in protecting its member states means that expanding its influence over the Ukraine is important from a security point of view. While regional stability is paramount, most responses to the Crimean annexation indicate an inclination towards peaceful resolution. European states prefer responses to the Crimean annexation that promote political and economic stability as opposed to retaliation through military aggression (The

Emergence of Terrorism in Nigeria and its Impacts on the Citizens

842 words - 4 pages and travellers who try to flee. “Eighty-seven bodies were recovered in the bush” (Maiangwa). This portrays the government as one which is not able to adequately protect the lives of the citizens. Food shortage is another effect of terrorism in Nigeria. The Northern part of the country produces a major part of Nigeria’s food. The supply of food from there however has been reduced thereby making available food more expensive which in turn causes

Similar Essays

Europe: The Lisbon Treaty Essay

2167 words - 9 pages The Lisbon treaty followed the disastrous Constitutional Treaty of 2004 that was rejected in referendums in France and the Netherlands. After a period of reflection, negotiations began for another treaty (Laursen, 2013:9). These negotiations continued for months, after which it was left to the Portuguese presidency to complete the Treaty, and thus the Treaty became known as the Lisbon Treaty. It was signed in Lisbon on 13 December 2007, but

Lisbon Treaty Essay

2224 words - 9 pages different from the one in which it was first conceived from 2002-2003 and later approved. Whether the new Treaty's provisions on NPs contributes to strengthening EU's democratic legitimacy or to creating major problems for EU decision making will depend on both the use of the "yellow" and "orange" card procudures for ensuring respect for the subsidiary principle, and on the rising influence of NPs on theri governments. The Lisbon Treaty is a

The Lisbon Treaty And Its Consequences On The European Union Decision Making

1229 words - 5 pages decided to create a new treaty that builds upon the Treaty on the European Union (Maastricht 1992), and the Treaty Establishing the European Community (Rome 1957), whereas the constitution would start anew by replacing all earlier EU treaties. Recently, both Ireland and Czech Republic were the last to ratify the treaty. In 2008, the Irish population rejected the Lisbon Treaty through a referendum. However, in October 2009, after some concessions

Treaty Between Britain And France In The Life Of King Henry V By William Shakespeare

1253 words - 6 pages war, a peace treaty was made, and part of that agreement was the marriage between King Henry V and the daughter of the King of France, Katherine of Valois. An analysis of the both King Henry’s and Katherine’s relationship reveals that both had conflicting perspectives of one another, which resulted as a marriage in political unions of two powerful nations rather than a union of two lovers. Throughout history, especially in the fifteenth century