Comparison Of Philippine Insurrection And Vietnam War

1406 words - 6 pages

There are many similarities and differences between the Philippine Insurrection of the late nineteenth century and the Vietnam War of the late twentieth century. Types of warfare and atrocities committed during both conflicts are comparable, while factors such as war objectives and motivations differ greatly. I personally feel that the United States had a better cause for fighting the Vietnam War, even though it was our first major military defeat. Despite the American loss, it was more worthwhile to fight in the Vietnam War than in the Philippine Insurrection because the United States had a more laudable reason for involvement. American involvement in the Philippine crisis represented a brave new step for the country because it had emerged from its former state of isolation. However, by the time the Vietnam War began, America felt obligated to participate simply because it was the most powerful nation in the world militarily and had much experience in warfare and foreign relations.
Vietnam struggled for its independence from France in the First Indochina War. It was divided into North Vietnam, which fell under the control of Communists, and South Vietnam, which attempted to establish a republican form of government. The Northern Vietnamese were determined to reunite Vietnam under Communist rule. However, the United States subscribing to the “Domino Theory” was determined to prevent this from occurring (Encarta). Essentially, this theory stated that if one country fell under Communist rule, then many others would follow in a chain reaction, or domino effect (Encarta). The United States was resolute upon containing communism and spreading capitalism and democracy, and therefore supported South Vietnam’s resistance to attacks from the North. Ultimately, the North Vietnamese succeeded in uniting North and South Vietnam, and this was America’s first major military defeat.
A much different situation existed prior to the Philippine Insurrection of the late nineteenth century. Realizing that this was a war and not an insurrection is important. First, the United States was not in control of the Philippines at the outbreak of war, so the Filipinos were not rebelling against any established authority (Sumodobila). Secondly, the fighting was between two organized forces representing two different interests, the United States and the Philippine Republic (Sumodobila). Also, the connotation of the term insurrection takes away the dignity from those who fought in the war and is a humiliation to the Filipinos (Sumodobila). At this time, the United States was mainly an isolated country, partaking minimally in foreign affairs. However, the United States was beginning to become more involved in international problems, especially those occurring in its own hemisphere. According to the Monroe Doctrine, the United States would take action if any foreign power attempted to colonize lands that had already established independence or were seeking...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Philippine Insurrection and Vietnam War

The Vietnam War and Iraq Essay

1261 words - 5 pages During the Vietnam War, between 1955 and 1984, fifty-eight thousand Americans lost their lives, as well as over three-million Vietnamese lost theirs. The financial cost to the United States comes to over one hundred-fifty-billion dollars. The causes of the Vietnam War were derived from the symptoms, components and consequences of the Cold War. The Vietnam War revolved around America’s belief that communism was a threat to expand all over South

Johnson and the Vietnam War Essay

946 words - 4 pages Johnson and the Vietnam War He was determined that he would not be held responsible for allowing Vietnam to fall to the Communists. Johnson believed that the key to success in the war in South Vietnam was to frighten North Vietnam's leaders with the possibility of full-scale U.S. military intervention. In January 1964 he approved top-secret, covert attacks against North Vietnamese territory, including commando raids against bridges

Australia and the Vietnam war

4074 words - 16 pages AUSTRALIA AND VIETNAMOn the 29th of April 1965, Australia Prime Minister Menzies formally announced Australia's participation in the Vietnam War and explained it in the following terms:The takeover of South Vietnam would be a direct military threat to Australia and all the countries of South and Southeast Asia. It must be seen as part of a trust by Communist China between the India and Pacific Oceans.Furthermore, Menzies highlighted that

The Significance of Vietnam War

1710 words - 7 pages The Significance of The Vietnam War Within one generation, The United States have experienced The Second World War, The Korean War and fifteen years of The Cold War crisis. The Vietnam War was the last drop into the cup of American patience. The costs of The Vietnam War were intolerable, because they contravened traditional American values and hopes. In the year 1965, American government announced, with public support, that America is going to

Overview Of The Vietnam War

786 words - 4 pages In the 1950's the United States, began to send armed forces over to Vietnam, for the following 20 plus years the ongoing war would create major tensions throughout U.S. History. Nearly 3 million U.S. service men and women were sent thousands of miles away from home, to fight for a rather questionable cause. In total nearly 2 and a half million people from both the U.S. and Vietnam would die in a fight that had no true point. For the

The Vietnam War and Vietnam's War History

1012 words - 4 pages World War 2 the French decided that they wanted Indochina back. They did not have enough power though at the time, so they decided to look for help from other countries, such as Britain. Their attempt at retaking Vietnam was an utter failure, and the French retreated from Vietnam following their defeat at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu. Ngo Dinh Diem was the Premier of South Vietnam beginning in 1954. He was an anti communist, and had his own very

A Comparison of World War I and World War II

980 words - 4 pages A Comparison of World War I and World War II World War I and World War II, while started by much of the same worldwide tensions, had drastically different results because of the much more destructive nature of World War II

The Vietnam War: Affects on America and Vietnam

2426 words - 10 pages and Photographs. London: Brassey's, 1997McNamara, Robert S. In Retrospect: The Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam. New York: Times Books, 1995Nixon, Richard M. No More Vietnams. New York: Arbor House, 1985Vo Nguyen Giap. People's War, People's Army: The Viet Cong Insurrection Manual for Undeveloped Countries. New York Fredrich Praefer, 1962

Vietnam War Themes in Books Wandering Souls and The Sorrow of War

2825 words - 11 pages Themes of a Soldier’s War The Vietnam War was hard for the country to handle, let alone a single soldier. Many soldiers dealt with different personal and physiological effects of this war. This war in Vietnam was different than any of the other wars. This war was unconventional, when we first entered it was more about the fight against the spread of communism then slowly changed over the years. Going into Vietnam was different in all senses

The Vietnam Conflict The Vietnam War was a long and

3733 words - 15 pages The Vietnam Conflict The Vietnam War was a long and frustrating experience for the American people. Even before the United States involvement began, North and South Vietnam were in conflict with each other. ?When Vietnam was divided in 1954, many Viet Minh who had been born in the southern part of the country returned to their native villages to await the 1956 elections and the reunification of their nation?(Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia 99

COMPARISON OF THE EDUCATION SYSTEM BETWEEN VIETNAM AND THE UNITED STATES

788 words - 3 pages system of Vietnam and the United States will now be explored.The first thing that is different is the structure of the education system. In Vietnam, the structure is 5-4-3; five years of elementary school (grades 1-5), followed by four years of secondary school (grades 6-9), and three years of high school (grades 10-12). Higher education programs last between two and six years. In the United States, the structure is 5-3-4. However, both the U.S

Similar Essays

A Critical Comparison Of The Role Of The Media During The War In Vietnam And World War 2

2666 words - 11 pages conflicts that I am going to compare will be the war in Vietnam, which has long been argued, was lost by the American media, and also the Second World War.Firstly I am going to discuss the origins of the war reporter, and how this has evolved and changed over time and how this may be relevant to differences in the reporting of the two conflicts.The role of a war correspondent was first coined during the Crimean war in the mid nineteenth century. (Russell

Overivew Of Vietnam War Essay

2144 words - 9 pages that France’s expulsion from the region would be accompanied by a communist takeover of Vietnam, Acheson petitioned Truman into committing logistical and financial support to France’s efforts in suppressing the Vietminh insurrection (Murray-7). Although the Vietminh had distinguished itself in fighting against Japanese occupation during the Second World War, it was evident that the movement was being affected by factionalism and ideological

Overview Of Vietnam War Essay

1927 words - 8 pages Soviet Union; and at the end of the Red Scare, the United States attempted to stop the spread of Communism. The Vietnam War was never officially declared a war by Congress, but rather deemed a “conflict.” The “Conflict” began as a “proxy war” under President Eisenhower and Kennedy, but fully escalated under Lyndon B. Johnson and Richard Nixon. Although the American people wanted end the spread of Communism, the Vietnam War received a vast amount of

A Comprehensive Comparison Of The Iraq And Vietnam Wars

2699 words - 11 pages , there have still been least fifty coalition casualties a month for the past ten months. [11] To add to this, there has still yet to be any evidence of weapons of mass destruction found, which was the main argument for a war in the first place. With the escalation of violence and civil disorder in Iraq, the situation has become strikingly similar to the Vietnam War. There has been mounting global pressure to bring an end to the war. There has also