Correctional Culture And The Limitations Of Oversight: A Bourdieusian Analysis Of Penal Governance

1094 words - 5 pages

In an era dominated by a political culture promoting rhetoric centred on being “tough on crime,” protecting “victim’s rights,” and creating “safe streets and communities,” the study of injustice, and the pursuit of protection for prisoner’s human rights within the correctional landscape might be perceived as a losing battle. However, in the wake of the coroner’s investigation and subsequent finding of homicide in the death of Ashley Smith, questions are being raised regarding the care and custody of an inmate population that is increasingly racialized, gendered, and medicalized. Accountability and transparency in corrections are words that flow freely, but frequently contradict the reality. ...view middle of the document...

Using a Bourdieu inspired lens, I position the relationship between the Correctional Investigator of Canada (further CIC) and the Correctional Service of Canada (further CSC) as one which embodies specific “divisions of labour,” each having contradicting priorites (Bourdieu 1987: 818). Thus, an inevitable “symbolic struggle” (Bourdieu 1991/2011: 454) manifests as each agent seeks to establish their sense of place, and ultimately their position of power, within the correctional “habitus” (ibid: 448). It is my intention in this essay to structure my analysis of the power dynamics inherrent in Canada’s correctional institution using Bourdieusian theoretical constructs, in an effort to highlight their applicability to social phenomena, and to showcase his contributions to contemporary sociological debates.
Agents within the Correctional Habitus
The CSC is, “responsible for 57 institutions and 84 parole offices and sub-offices in Canada” (Correctional Service of Canada 2010). The CSC’s responsibility includes the care and custody of federally sentenced adults, with a minimum sentence of two years. The number of federally sentenced inmates in the custody of the CSC is estimated between 13,000 and 15,000 (Brosnahan 2013, Waller and Piché 2012). The Commissioner of Corrections reports to the Minister of Public Safety, who in turn, reports to Parliament on the activities of the CSC.
The primary mandate of the CSC is public security; accordingly, the CSC seeks to control offenders while they are in custody (Correctional Service of Canada 2008). However, CSC is responsible for ensuring safe, secure and humane conditions of confinement for inmates and staff, and must additionally provide opportunities for offender rehabilitation prior to community release (Correctional Service of Canada 2008). The CSC is governed by several key pieces of legislation, not the least of which includes: the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, the Corrections and Conditional Release Regulations, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Criminal Code of Canada and the Canadian Human Rights Act.
In Bourdieu’s terms, these legal “texts” form the basis for the moralization of not just the offenders, but for the CSC as well. They work to responsibilize the agents working within the correctional habitus, but also, they provide a public demonstration that the law embodies, “impartiality and neutrality” which suggests that we are all equal and accountable under the law (Bourdieu 1987: 810). Further, Bourdieu asserts that a social field...

Find Another Essay On Correctional Culture and the Limitations of Oversight: A Bourdieusian Analysis of Penal Governance

The Ethics and Limitations of Animal Research

1871 words - 7 pages limitations related to the matter? It appears to be a challenge to find common ground concerning the above questions. This paper will first present the current guidelines of animal research, and what is being done to help preserve the suffering and health animals as much as possible. In order to have a full insight on the matter, it is also needed to present the main methods of animal research. Scientists have used animals in many research projects or

The Definition and Limitations of Harm

1536 words - 6 pages are also necessary for his overall definition to be viable. Without such limitations, society could restrict any action the majority of the population finds disagreeable. The actions an individual is at liberty to do would become limited, and Mill’s liberty principle would transform into “a law on the minority” (Mill 88). For example, vegetarians or vegans could insist that an individual should not eat meat, citing that it insults their morals

Nazi Appeal And The Limitations Of Democracy

2144 words - 9 pages unstable, and humiliated on the global stage, Germany was ill-suited to adopt a democratic government yet it did exactly this. The Weimar Republic, a parlimentary democracy, was thus born into a less than enthusiastic German nation in 1919 (Spielvogel 11-12).         In 1923, the French moved in to occupy the industrial Ruhr region, further exacerbating the soaring inflation of Weimar Germany. The government responded by employing

The Statute of Limitations

810 words - 3 pages other hand, the state does not implement caps on attorney’s fees (Medical Malpractice, 2011). The purpose statute of limitations is to ensure the credibility and integrity of the claim for medical malpractice by limiting the time frame to which a claimant can file a case. The scope of the statute of limitations includes not just the length of time but also the amount of recovery to be given and the attorney’s fees. This paper shows the different

Limitations of the Paparazzi

1424 words - 6 pages The paparazzi can receive up to thousands of dollars for candid pictures of celebrities. As celebrities become more popular, the public wants to know what their doing every second of every day, even when they aren’t on camera. The paparazzi make it their job to find those things out Paparazzi are photographers who repeatedly hunt celebrities, public figures and their families for a chance to photograph them in candid, unflattering and at times

Limitations of the Gods

833 words - 4 pages , words disputatious, lying words, and lawlessness. The last child of Eris is Oath, which could be a way to try and balance out to bad with some good. From the old male gods, Ouranos's severed genitalia gave form to Aphrodite and Pontos, the sea, gave form to Nereus. (93) While the eldest gods could produce children on their own, only a one of the later gods possessed that ability. Hera had Hephaestus (104) all on her own, with no male to aid her

A Survey on the Limitations of Graphical Password Scheme and the Mitigation of Proposed System

1644 words - 7 pages vulnerable to shoulder surfing and hidden cameras. A. Perrig and D. Song [5] review about the security systems that bear from the fact that they fail to account for human factors. This paper considers two human limitations. Initially the people are slow and undependable in comparing the worthless strings and on the other hand people have some difficulties in detecting the strong passwords or PINs. In this method they enhanced the security of

The Mission of the Correctional System

1291 words - 5 pages correctional system. Repeat offenders are somewhat common, which suggest that rehabilitation efforts do not work well. Incarceration of criminals is expensive. “The cost of building a prison runs upward of $ 100.000 per cell, excluding financing.”(Correctional Budgets 2010) Similarly, the criminal prosecution process is expensive. “In addition to paying the salaries of judges and district attorneys, the state must pay for criminal defense attorneys for

A Discussion Of The Strengths And Limitations Of Richard White's Thesis

1595 words - 7 pages The following essay will discuss the strengths and limitations presented by Richard White (Images of Australia) regarding the factors that have contributed to the making of the Australian national identity. Focussing the essay on the Anzac legend, this essay will be approached and supported with the appropriate supporting evidence and as this paper proposes that the answer is based on opinion, the use of some non-academic references will be

Government Oversight of Corporate Finances

613 words - 2 pages This subject could be debated endlessly due to the fact that politics comes into play when you discuss "government" anything. Democrats will say that this would not be necessary if a Republican was not in office and the Republicans will say that had the previous Democrat done his job we would not be at this state. Having made this point, we will try not to focus on the political aspect but on the realistic aspect of our economy's current

The Strengths and Limitations of the Biological Model of Abnormality

796 words - 3 pages The Strengths and Limitations of the Biological Model of Abnormality This model uses physical illness as a model for psychological disorder, suggesting that like physical illness, mental illness has an underlying bodily cause. It proposes that genetic, organic or chemical disorders cause metal illnesses which give rise to

Similar Essays

The Penal And Judiciary System: The High Cost Of Incarceration

2280 words - 9 pages intended to reform and rehabilitate offenders of society’s laws; however, America’s prison system usually makes matters much worse for the offender, his or her family, and society as a whole. The illustrations below show that there is a severe need for reform in the penal system. There are several fundamental problems within America’s penal system. First, the name “penal” system indicates that the main focus is punishment. Punishment is meant to

Oversight Of Mk Ultra And Prism Essay

3293 words - 13 pages atrocities of the past. In order to see how far the intelligence community, and particularly oversight, has come in recent years, it is important to understand the failures of the past. In the final days before the end of World War II, the United States and the Soviet Union were scavenging the German hillsides on a treasure hunt. The treasure they were seeking was not gold or jewels, it was information. They were looking for new aircraft

A Survey On The Limitations Of Graphical

766 words - 4 pages Chris Davies and Ravi Ganesan [11] reviews about the weakly chosen passwords continue to be a major source of security problems and it is vulnerable to dictionary attacks. In this method BApasswd a new proactive password checker is projected and this component is used for password varying program that attempts to validate the eminence of a password chosen by the user, before the selection is finalized. When the user had given a password, this

Report And Analysis Of Corporate Governance

2193 words - 9 pages system. It has ensured monitoring covered all activities by the oversight regulatory body. As a result, it can reveals that by performing this activity help to ensure board and committee evaluations and also enhance the information flow within company (Marks and Spencer, 2013) Moreover, The Governance Framework of M&S has been confirm by the Board and is published on the website, Therefore, shareholders and other key stakeholders can see the standards