Crimes And Misdemeanors Essay

2631 words - 11 pages

Judah Rosenthal is a prosperous ophthalmologist, a father, a husband and a generous donator to charity: he has all the traits of a noble man, but has a secret. He has had an affair for the past two years, and now the hysterically in love woman is threatening to expose him to his wife and to the rest of the world. Crushed by fear and torment, Judah resolves to have her murdered. Despite the brutality of his choice, it is not a simple task for him, even though he has always been skeptical towards the Jewish traditions he learned from his father and being himself a man of science. Murder had never been taken into consideration before now. It is the sin of sins, the highest depravation of ...view middle of the document...

For Aristotle, man has to try and develop oneself to the maximum in order to reach a full realization of oneself.

However, with the coming of Christianity a new view of morality emerged: a religious one. This approach to morality is profoundly God-centered and God is the prime formulator of rules and duties that tell us how we ought to live. We can decide to accept or reject them, but disobeying God’s commandments equals to immorality. A figure throughout Crimes and Misdemeanors that seems to personify this religious approach to morality is Sol, Judah’s father. We learn from Judah’s speech that in his youth his father taught him to know how God sees everything, and those who are righteous will be rewarded while those who are wicked will be punished for eternity. And it is exactly these religious teachings that torment Judah after committing the murder of his mistress Dolores. He sees himself as a man of science therefore has always been skeptical towards his Jewish upbringing, but the crime he has committed throws him into a vortex of thought that makes him reconsider a sort of higher moral structure of the world. His fear of being punished for eternity pushes him to the verge of confession, but he seems to be pulled in two directions: that of his father, in which no deed can be unpunished, and that of his aunt May, for whom might equals right.

An emblematic sequence in regards to this aspect can be seen during the dining table scene. While trying to register his horrific crime, Judah revisits his childhood home to seek some comfort. New tenants now occupy the house, and for the first part of his visit it remains a picturesque memory of his childhood. Suddenly he hears forks clinging and chattering from the dining room and moments later he finds himself in his own flashback: Judah is standing in the dining room of one of his family’s past Seder dinners where the dialogue at the dinner table copes with the possibility of a universe with no God. The argument takes place between Sol and May, the two opposite philosophical approaches. Religious Sol is firmly convinced that evil will always be punished in some way or another; while May insists there is no God, no nothing. In a very interesting speech, she affirms that if the man who commits evil gets away with it and ‘chooses not to be bothered by the ethics, then he’s home free.’ She also adds that ‘history is written by the winners’, referring to Hitler and to his possible victory of World War II. All this information appears both puzzling and promising to Judah, but this sequence is an excellent portray of his inner turmoil. He is being pushed to one side then to the other, completely losing control of himself.

Another figure that may personify religious morality is that of the rabbi Ben. Ben is also he who ties together the stories of Judah and Cliff, as he is Lester’s brother (therefore Cliff’s brother-in-law) and Judah’s patient. Before deciding the unthinkable, Judah confesses his need...

Find Another Essay On crimes and misdemeanors

State Comparison Essay

665 words - 3 pages 27 districts in 36 counties and is home to 166 judges. The circuit courts deal with cases such as: some small claims ($5,000 limit), adoptions, misdemeanors, exclusive felonies, traffic/ other violations, juveniles, and many more.The California court systems are divided into State and Federal. With the state court system, it is broken down into Trail Courts and Appellate Courts. There are 58 trial courts, also known as Superior Courts, within

Types of Crimes Essay

663 words - 3 pages less severe penalty. Misdemeanors that aren’t as serious are known as petty offenses. Driving an automobile without a license, lying about your age to purchase alcohol, and leaving the scene of an automobile accident are all examples of misdemeanors. Crimes are defined by two elements. The first element is the criminal act. Every law that defines a crime must specifically explain the conduct that is forbidden by that law. The criminal act

Juvelines Tried as Adults in Court

819 words - 3 pages minors. Juvenile offenders are not only a threat to a town doing ?small crimes? or misdemeanors but are committing more serious crimes as time goes by and yet still no efforts has been made to keep criminals where they belong. In the Kent Vs United States Trial a young offender 16years of age was charged with rape and because juveniles do not get the same rights as adults Kent?s attorney was not allowed to review any files that where obtained

Juveniles Tried As Adults

575 words - 2 pages murder and adult crimes.Crimes such as rape and murder are adult crimes. For example, if a child is capable enough to determine that they would be willing to take the life of another human being, then they are capable enough to be put in prison for the appointed amount of time, whether it is 10 years, or life. In addition, crime?s cost to society is the same regardless of the criminal?s age. Furthermore, felonies and misdemeanors are erased from a

Crime and Punishment

899 words - 4 pages and medical purposes. The punishments for felonies varied in severity. The punishments could be death by hanging or to be beheaded. The many misdemeanors that a person could commit are begging, forgery, being in debt, petty theft, adultery, and fraud. Generally, the punishments for these crimes were whipping, starvation, burning at the stake, removal of limbs, and hanging, and branding. The Nobility class were generally the ones who committed

William Shakespeare

987 words - 4 pages involved a plot against the throne" (Stewart 79). Punishments in Elizabethan Times depended on how severe the crime was. The worst punishment however, were reserved for people who planning to go against the throne. "During Shakespeare's times, criminal action was divided into three main categories: treason, felonies, and misdemeanors. Treason was by far the most serious of all crimes, and the playwright reflected this fact in several of his plays

Crime. Speaks of how they can be classified in different ways

2082 words - 8 pages growing urban society." These crimes include violations of income tax laws, liquor control regulations, pure food and drug laws, and traffic laws. Crimes in the first group usually involve severe punishments while crimes in the second group are generally punished by fines, notices to follow the court's orders, or other relatively light penalties.Crimes are frequently classified according to their seriousness as felonies or misdemeanors. Generally

Legal brief essay-3 strikes case

1078 words - 4 pages “But it was only a few lousy videotapes!” was probably what Leonardo Andrade thought as he was placed behind bars for life because of the Three Strikes law passed in March of 1994. After being a long-time heroin addict and with a 15-year criminal history consisting of 5 felonies and 2 misdemeanors, was given the sentence of 25 years to life, after attempting to steal videotapes from a local store. The petty theft crime was a crime

Age of Responsibility

617 words - 2 pages ,” lawmakers have “passed countless laws that have made it easier to try minors as adults” (Greenblatt). But as most of the criminal infractions are centered around drug crimes, misdemeanors, and minor infractions, these laws have made it easier to put undeserving young people into adult facilities to further worsen their state. As states are starting to rethink the harshness of the law to try them as adults, they see that if kids are put into

Should Juveniles Offenders be Tried and Punished as Adults?

682 words - 3 pages offender. Based on the crime Every offense is different from case to case. There are two types of crimes a misdemeanor and a felony. Misdemeanors are small nonviolent crimes such as a drug charge under twenty grams, and accessory to a crime; where they’re at the wrong place at the wrong time. That carries only a maximum sentence of twelve months in a county jail. A felony is a serious crime such as kidnapping, murder, rape, arson or a drug charge

Andrew Johnson: Successor to Abraham Lincoln

1208 words - 5 pages impeached and removed from office. “It is undoubted that every Republican member of the Senate entered upon that trial in the expectation that the allegations of the Prosecution would be sustained.” (Ross, History of the Impeachment of Andrew Johnson, President of the United States, by the House of Representatives and His Trial by the Senate for High Crimes and Misdemeanors in Office) “To sum up this feature of the proceeding – the Republican

Similar Essays

Crimes And Misdemeanors Essay

1110 words - 5 pages . These views were both demonstrated in the film “Crimes and Misdemeanors”. Each of those views make an impact on how one lives their lives, and the circumstances associated with each view. Taking a look at the differences and similarities of psychological egoism and ethical egoism is the first step to understanding the complex characters in this film. Steven M. Cahn explains in Exploring Ethics that “psychological egoism is the view that all

Ethics In Crimes And Misdemeanors Essay

700 words - 3 pages Ethical Dilemmas in Crimes and Misdemeanors There are two plots in Crimes and Misdemeanors, which oddly parallel each other. In one story, the "Crime" story, Judah Rosenthal, an apparently happily married and successful ophthalmologist, life is on the verge of disintegration because Delores, mistress of two years, wants to reveal their relationship. Juda is not a religious man, yet he consults Rabbi Ben, whose advice to confess and seek

Analysis Of The Movie Crimes And Misdemeanors

705 words - 3 pages Released in 1989, Crimes and Misdemeanors outlines the lives of two men; Cliff Stern and Judah Rosenthal. Cliff Stern, a small time film-maker, struggles to succeed in both his career and marriage. While Judah Rosenthal, a wealthy ophthalmologist, faces moral dilemmas after having an affair with a young mistress. Judah's mistress expects him to leave his wife and when he doesn't she threatens to expose the secret relationship. Unsure Judah

Crime Essay

875 words - 4 pages misdemeanors serve their sentence in city, or county jails, or correction houses.      Crimes against people include assault, kidnapping, murder, and sexual attacks. Such crimes usually bring severe punishments. Crimes against property include arson, automobile theft, burglary, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, larceny, and vandalism. In most cases, these crimes carry lighter penalties than the crimes set against the person