Was The Treaty Of Versailles Fair? By Laura Aberle

947 words - 4 pages

Was the Treaty of Versailles Fair? - by Laura AberleWho can say for sure whether the Treaty of Versailles was fair or not? The answer depends on your point of view. From the French perspective, the Germans deserved to give up everything in order to make amends for the destruction they caused in France. Therefore, the treaty wasn't punishing them enough. From where the American and British leaders were standing, it seemed impossible to place the entire blame on one country, so the Clause 231 must have seemed quite harsh. But the treaty was a compromise - no one got everything they wanted, but more importantly, no one was completely short-changed. Not even Germany. Many of Wilson's peaceful Fourteen Points weren't accomplished, but he had faith in the League of Nations to sort things out later. Clemenceau had wanted nothing but revenge on Germany, and that was definitely achieved, if not to the extent he had hoped for. Lloyd-George was probably the most content out of the three leaders, because he had wanted a compromise between the French and American ideas to begin with.What about Germany? Wasn't it unfair to place the entire blame on her, and to make her pay such hefty reparations? It might be argued that the treaty was aimed at completely destroying Germany's economy and that they had lost too much territory and money. People worried that their army would be ruined by it as well. It was argued that the politicians who signed the treaty were tricked because they had thought only Wilson's Fourteen Points had been used in writing it.Perhaps it was rather severe to make the Germans agree that the entire war had been their fault, but those are only words. The reparations they had to pay because of their guilt were still relatively small, considering the amount the French would have liked to take. The economy was obviously not destroyed because Germany was soon the most successful nation in Europe again. In 1925, it was producing twice as much steel as Britain. Very little European territory was taken, and what was given away was mostly inhabited by people who considered themselves as Polish or French. Although the army was reduced, the generals were still there, and ready to rebuild. Isn't it hypocritical of Germany to complain and say they were tricked, when they had only taken the Fourteen Points seriously once they'd been beaten? They had also forced the harsh peace treaty of Brest-Litovsk on Russia in 1918 without worries. It could seem that, in their rage about having all the guilt on them, the Germans set out to make the treaty look much worse than it really was.Did the Big Three also feel cheated? Despite the whines heard from Germany about the brutality of the...

Find Another Essay On Was the Treaty of Versailles Fair? - by Laura Aberle

Why Germany was So Discontented with The Treaty of Versailles

2494 words - 10 pages Versailles in France: the exact place where, after the 1871 war for Alsace-Lorraine was won by the Germans, the new borderline country of Germany was formed. This was a very great piece of history for the Germans and to be brought back to the same area by the smug French was embarrassing for them. During the time the peace treaty as being deliberated, Great Britain was still using its naval tactic of blockading as an

The Treaty of Versailles was Too Harsh on Germany

1115 words - 4 pages The Treaty of Versailles was Too Harsh on Germany I think that the treaty of Versailles was harsh on Germany because even though they were a part of the war, so were the allies, yet they didn't take any blame for the war. The French wanted revenge and Wilson wanted peace. These two, conbined, still made a harsh treaty. Lloyd George tried to get a 'halfway point' between the two but ended up going mostly to France

Was the Treaty of Versailles the Major Cause of World War Two?

1422 words - 6 pages to get the French and Belgians to consent to decrease the amount of money that Germany would need to pay to reimburse them for war destruction, (Treaty of Versailles, Text of Article 231 the "War Guilt Clause”). The clause was severely hated by practically every German because of their belief that they were not accountable for the outburst of the conflict, (Treaty of Versailles, Text of Article 231, the "War Guilt Clause): "The Allied and

Was the Treaty of Versailles the Major Cause of World War Two?

1170 words - 5 pages World War Two was the most devastating conflict in the history of mankind. It crimpled many nations and caused millions of people to die. One of the major causes of this disastrous war was the Treaty of Versailles which ended the First World War. This treaty was destructive towards the Germans. Germany had to pay large amounts of reparations to the Allied nations at the end of World War One resulting in a Great Depression in Germany

The Treaty of Versailles Was the Most Pleasing to Woodrow Wilson or George Clemenceau?

2406 words - 10 pages The Treaty of Versailles Was the Most Pleasing to Woodrow Wilson or George Clemenceau? After the First World War a treaty had to be made to punish Germany for their actions. This had to be done as Germany had lost the war and had signed the Armistice on the 11th November 1918. The German peoples were hungry, war weary and demanded peace. The Paris peace conference's job was to write the Treaty of Versailles. Britain

Was Hitler alone the cause of world war two?- essay title summerised answer: only partly, due to other reasons such as the Treaty of Versailles, The Great Depression and more

547 words - 2 pages Treaty of Versailles had further effects than the crippling of German military power and economy. It was an insult, which the Germans could not overcome, and was to be one of the major forces of World War II. Many who were against the Weimar government from the start, and later the Nazi party in its rise to power, would describe the Treaty as a "stab-in-the-back" by traitors such as Jews and communists, later named the "November Criminals", who

The Treaty of Versailles

1802 words - 7 pages was not a "peace treaty" but a truce in a European thirty-year civil war.The Treaty of Versailles disarmed Germany, demilitarized the Rhineland (the German territory west of the River Rhine), and shrank German and Austro- Hungarian territory to make room for a series of new states aimed at buffering Germany to the east. It imposed blame for the war on Germany in the famous War Guilt Clause and, by extension, forced it to pay over thirty billion

The Treaty of Versailles

3241 words - 13 pages harsh reparations, the “War Guilt Clause,” and the humiliation the Germans suffered from French occupation in the west. Adolf Hitler manipulated the German intolerance with the Versailles Treaty to push Germany into several confrontations that eventually resulted in World War II. Hitler maintained that the second world war was caused by the Treaty’s “iniquities,” (35) concerning the harsh conditions of the document. Chambers et al state that “…in

The Treaty Of Versailles

1690 words - 7 pages The Treaty Of Versailles On June 28th, 1919, Germany was forced to sign the Treaty of Versailles in the hall of mirrors, within the palace of Versailles, practically against her will. The Treaty, having been made up by the Triple Entente leaders Lloyd George and George Clemenceau, and Woodrow Wilson of the USA, was unfair to Germany, but she had no choice. Germany's options were to sign the treaty within 48 hours or be

The Treaty of Versailles

1185 words - 5 pages nations and cause 30 nations another great depression. World war II began because during world war I the treaty of versailles was very helpful to end war but not for germany because germany land was taken away also many of germany territories. Including german weapons was confiscated like tanks and other things like submarines. Germany felt weakened by these rules and 1.5 million german troops invaded poland all along its 1,750 mile border to Hitler

Speech on Dreams. - by Laura Aberle

570 words - 2 pages was the case in the following example:A woman was awfully afraid of spiders. In a dream a big spider was approaching her. The hairy crawler came nearer and nearer, until it touched her. But she felt quiet, and not afraid. Afterwards she noticed that by day she was no longer afraid of spiders either.Sounds amazing? Well, this is not at all as mysterious as it sounds. 'Overcoming your fear' in this way is also possible in your dream. Nightmares can

Similar Essays

Was The Treaty Of Versailles A Fair Treaty? Explain

723 words - 3 pages It is difficult to decide whether the treaty of Versailles was a fair or an unfair treaty - it depends on the point of view, but I personally think that the treaty was quite harsh and unfair... The main reason why I think that this treaty was quite unfair is that Germany didn't have a say in its own future, and I think that, despite all, Germany should have had the opportunity to go to Versailles and to discuss together with all the other

The Treaty Of Versailles Fair Or Unfair?

632 words - 3 pages well as others. The Treaty of Versailles was unfair.Punishing Germany harshly is what the French dreamed of. From their perspective, the treaty was not fair enough and that it should have been harsher. France wanted full revenge on Germany for the destruction they caused to France during the war. Clemenceau's ideal outcome would have been to see Germany destroyed by the treaty. The French felt unsafe being so close to the Germans as they did not

How Was Germany Punished By The Treaty Of Versailles?

548 words - 2 pages How Was Germany Punished At Versailles?Germany was punished severely by the Treaty of Versailles, and in many cases, some of the terms seemed greatly unfair towards Germany. The treaty was put together by Woodrow Wilson – who wasn’t very keen on punishing Germany too harshly, as he believed that Germany would be intent on seeking revenge in the future, Georges Clemenceau – who wanted to punish Germany for France’s losses, and

How Harsh Was The Treaty Of Versailles?

976 words - 4 pages country in ruins) and to a certain extent England led Lloyd George. The treaty of Versailles was mostly written by Clemenceau. His intentions were therefore simple: he wanted punitive reparations and Germany's army to be not only weakened for the time being, but permanently weakened so as never to be able to invade France again. Clemenceau was old enough to remember the invasion of Prussia in the 1870's and the humiliation which France suffered