Is The Reader Expected To View The Signalman's Account Of Events As Reliable In Charles Dickens' Story "The Signalman"?

762 words - 3 pages

The story "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens, is a ghost story set by a railway line. Dickens writes the story in the 1st person, as if he himself is meeting the signalman with the disturbing past. The story is slightly unclear, however, as to whether the audience are expected to accept the signalman's version of events or to question them.The narrators own view of the signalman's version of evens wavers throughout the story. To start with, he is intimidated by the signalman's appearance and doubts his sanity. Later on he learns of the signalman's background and starts to believe him. Towards the end of the tale he again doubts of the signalman's sanity as he suspect that the signalman is subject to paranoia, and he tries to find logical explanations.The audience's perception of the story depends on how the signalman's account is read. The genre of the story also depends on your decision to accept or question his account. If you accept his version of events, the story is a ghost story full of tragic disasters and vague warnings. If you question him, the story becomes a psychological thriller which takes you on his descent into madness.There are many references in the story that suggest that the signalman's version of events are reliable. The narrator discovers that the signalman is a well educated man, "perhaps educated above that staition...He had been, when young...a student of natural philosophy." (paragraph 12, lines 36 - 49). He also mentions the the work of the signalman, describing him as a man who was unscrupulous in his work, taking great pride in it and ignoring any distractions. "I had observed him to be exact and vigilant, breaking off his discourse at a syllable, and remaining silent until what he had to do was done." the fact that he was a good worker and student suggests that he was sane and reliable, as you'd need to be clear in thought to study philosophy and to work where hundreds of lives a day depended on you.The narrator attempts to influence readers views on the signalman's reliability by using sentences such as; "I should have set this man down as one of the safest men to be employed in that capacity..." (paragraph...

Find Another Essay On Is the reader expected to view the signalman's account of events as reliable in Charles Dickens' story "The Signalman"?

Suspense and Tension in Charles Dickens' The Signalman

1585 words - 6 pages Suspense and Tension in Charles Dickens' The Signalman In the Charles Dickens' story the narrator meets the signalman who is confessing to him his problems. The narrator comes every night to find out that the signalman was seeing a ghost of a man, who was pointing out that certain train accidents are going to happen. After a few days the narrator goes peacefully to the signalman's shed, and finds out that he

Techniques Used by Charles Dickens to Create Mystery in The Signalman

1502 words - 6 pages direct connection. There is directly reported speech in the story, which can, due to the short and unfriendly responses from the signalman lead us to imagine a darker side to him. "I was doubtful," he returned, "whether I had seen you before." The story itself is not written in chronological order and Dickens makes as much use as he can of flashbacks, for instance when he is talking about the spectre. These make the reader more intrigued to

Charles Dickens: Creating Emotions for the Reader

2088 words - 8 pages Charles Dickens, the son of John and Elizabeth Dickens, was born in Landport on 7th February 1812. John Dickens worked as a clerk at the Navy pay office in Portsmouth. He later found work in Chatham and Charles; the second of seven children, went to the local school. Dickens father, John Dickens, found it extremely difficult to provide for his family on his meagre income. This resulted in the family being forced to sell most of their possessions

The Signalman, by Charles Dickens; The Battler by Ernest Hemingway

2556 words - 10 pages that Dickens wishes to portray the signalman as a dark and ominous figure. However, he then sheds some light on the character of the signalman. Dickens portrays him to be very lonely and afraid of something. This is shown in the way he 'turns himself about and looked down the Line' when the narrator calls to him. It is as if he is expecting something unusual. The narrator is obviously telling the story and almost introduces himself to be a

The Devices Charles Dickens Uses to Engage the Interest of the Reader

1524 words - 6 pages liver to eat, “should think himself accredited to my heart and liver to-night, instead of to-morrow!” While the reader at this point might find humour in it, they will also feel fear for Pip since he is very gullible. Dickens makes the ‘convict’s’ entry into the story very dramatic and exciting for the reader. We hear him say, “hold your noise” before even seeing him, and then he comes out from behind a grave as if he himself is a dead

Charles Dickens' The Signalman and A Birthday by Karen Mansfield

3910 words - 16 pages Charles Dickens' The Signalman and A Birthday by Karen Mansfield A signalman is a short story written by Charles Dickens. This is a story about a signalman who is driven “mad” by the environment of his work, away from sunlight and people. But he was not alone; a supernatural ghost decides to accompany him too. He has a lot of responsibilities to shoulder. There are only two characters that really are prominent in the short story

The Language in The Red Room by H G Wells and The Signalman by Charles Dickens

911 words - 4 pages The Language in The Red Room by H G Wells and The Signalman by Charles Dickens Throughout, The Signalman has suspense and the tension is gripping, as the author, Dickens, has used exceedingly good description in the language and the setting is just perfect. Dickens had an advantage when writing this story as there were similarities between himself and some of the characters; since he had been involved in a train

Compare 'The Signalman,' by Charles Dickens, and 'Lamb to the Slaughter,' by Roald Dahl and discuss how both authors generate a sense of suspense in the stories

802 words - 3 pages are still similarities. One of these is the way the authors feature death. An example of how Dickens uses death to sustain suspense throughout the story is the death of strangers. The two characters in 'The Signalman,' are both strangers to the reader. We don't even learn their names. This could have been because they were working class men. At the time it was written, it was considered there was no need to. As a consequence of their anonymity

Mystery in Charlotte Bronte's Napoleon and the Spectre and Charles Dickens' Signalman

2279 words - 9 pages of Evolution. These strong religious beliefs resulted in a reluctance by people to move forward and welcome new inventions. It was common at the time for people who held different opinions to be seen as anarchists, they were viewed as trouble makers distorting the minds of people and often imprisoned or killed. As with Bronte, Dickens' story also has a supernatural air about it, with a signalman who is placed 'at a lonesome post'. The

Compare the techniques used to create tension and fear in the two stories "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens and "The Landlady" by Roald Dahl

1248 words - 5 pages The two stories 'The Signalman' and 'The Landlady' are quite similar in the techniques used to create tension and fear, but the stories can also be very different in places.At the very start of each story, there are hints that lead to fear and tension. In 'The Signalman', there is a "glow of an angry sunset", which gives us an image of something that is hot, fierce, sinister, so we can build that up as the story continues. This also happens in

The Signalman by Charles Dickens and The Red Room by H G Wells

2245 words - 9 pages rational reasons to minimise strangeness of the 'spectre' that the signalman keeps seeing. The narrator talks of an 'infection in the mind' and 'deception of his sense of sight' and recommends the signalman to see a doctor, when he sees the ghost. Suprisingly Dickens tells us almost nothing about the narrator and he is scarcely viewed as a real person. At the end of the story it is possible to say that the narrator is a reliable narrator

Similar Essays

How Does Charles Dickens Use The Ghost Story Genre To Provoke Fear In Both Victorian And Modern Reader Of 'the Signalman'?

2318 words - 9 pages How does Charles Dickens use the ghost story genre to provoke fear in both Victorian and modern reader of 'The Signalman'?Ghost stories have many conventions. For example the setting is typically a dark gloomy place like a castle with thick fog and strange noises. Other conventions of the genre have the ghost being a white billowing shape floating above the ground. Sometimes, like in this story ghost story are used to explore things. For example

How Dickens Creates Atmosphere In The Opening Of "The Signalman" By Referring To The Way He Describes The Signalman's Character

566 words - 2 pages Dickens manages to create atmosphere in the beginning of "The Signalman" by portraying the signalman as a withdrawn and deliberate man. The way that the signalman looks down the tracks rather than upwards after being greeted by 'halloa! Below there'. A greeting which there could have been no confusion as to where it came from. This reveals to us that the signalman is a strange character with a somewhat indescribable manner of doing things.After

The Signalman By Charles Dickens Essay

3415 words - 14 pages making the reader feel nervous. i3DS Visit coursework dd in dd fo dd for dd more project dd Do dd not dd redistribute i3DS The Signalman's appearance is quite peculiar as is his behaviour. He looks at the bell when it does not ring and talks of a spectre, which has been appearing to him from the tunnel. Throughout the story, we are told that the signalman has sighted a spectre. He states, "That troubles me". He is clearly very worried and

Atmosphere In Charles Dickens' The Signalman

1213 words - 5 pages Atmosphere in Charles Dickens' The Signalman 'The Signal-man' is a ghostly thriller by Charles Dickens. Based on an apparently hallucinating signal-man and the tales of his hallucinations, the story is seen through the eyes of the narrator, a man told of the signal-mans troubles during conversations with the signal-man himself. From the beginning of the story, the atmosphere is both eerie and gloomy. To produce