Isn’t It Ironic That Two Stories Could Have Separate Accounts

1651 words - 7 pages

Isn?t it ironic that two stories could have separate accounts of irony, but still have similar characters? Irony could occur in everyday life. Sometimes in life, we could expect something wonderful to happen, but then find out something that is total opposite of what we had anticipated. In ?The Necklace? by Guy de Maupassant, the main character Mathilde Loisel was born into a middle class family, yet she often envied the upper society. She had attended a high society event that changed her life forever. In ?The Cask of Amontillado? by Edgar Allan Poe, the main character Fortunato, was played for a fool when his friend Montressor led him to his death. This essay will discuss the kinds of irony found in both ?The Necklace? and ?The Cask of Amontillado?; it will also show connections between Mathilde of ?The Necklace? and Fortunato of ?The Cask of Amontillado.? The first type of irony found in the ?The Necklace? is called situational. This kind of irony is when we expect one thing to happen, but something else does. Mathilde attended a high society party for just one night; however, this party had changed her society class status forever. Another example is when Mathilde borrowed a necklace from her friend. When she was looking through the jewelry, ?[a]ll at once she found, in a black satin box, a superb diamond necklace??(32,1,2) unfortunately, it had turned out to be a fake. The comparison of genuine verse in genuine was present through the story.Yet another example of situational irony is found in Poe?s ?The Cask of Amontillado.? We think that the story will be based on this cask of wine but in fact, the title of the story is a play on words for it is the cask, which leads Fortunato to his casket. The setting of the story takes place during carnival season where everyone should be smiling, laughing and having a good time. In deed, that?s not the case because there will be a premeditated murder about to unfold during this joyous season.Another kind of irony found in ?The Necklace? is called verbal. Verbal irony is when we say one thing, but we mean another. When Mathilde had met up with Mme. Forestier ten years after she had paid everything off, Mathilde said to her ?Yes, I?ve had a hard time since last seeing you. And plenty of misfortunes - and all on account of you!?(34,2,1) It wasn?t Mme. Forestier?s fault that Mathilde had suffered all these misfortunes. If Mathilde had been honest and told her friend the truth nothing like this would have happened.The main character of ?The Cask of Amontillado? is an example of verbal irony. Fortunato name means fortunate, which he is anything but. There are numerous examples of verbal irony within Montresor?s words. Montresor states that in spite of his decision of killing Fortunato, he continued smiling in his face (Fortunato?s), but he adds: ??and he did not perceive that my smile now was at the thought of his immolation?(35,1,2). So, when they meet each other they behaved as always, but now Montresor?s...

Find Another Essay On Isn’t it ironic that two stories could have separate accounts

Find an explanation to how cancer started. i took the proof that exists today of how cancer may have started and explained how joseph, son of jacob, could be responsible for it

1359 words - 5 pages interpretation, appointed him governor of Egypt to prepare for the famine. When the famine came, Joseph was the one that rationed the food. People rushed to Egypt from all around the world. Joseph again gained the praise he desired. Through all the hatred of his brothers and the tough times as a prisoner, he had to have gained disgust for the world and wanted retribution.Whether Joseph's talent to interpret dreams was real or not, it was unique

How is Italy and / or being Italian portrayed in the stories you have studied compare and contrast at least two short stories

2089 words - 8 pages This essay will discuss the portrayal of Italy and being Italian in the short stories I have studied. I have split this broad theme into smaller themes which are most prominent in the stories, they are also the themes that reflect Italy and the notion of being Italian.Italy as we know it has only been in existence for just over 140 years. Before this time it was a feudal unbalanced, divided collection of separate kingdoms. Before 1860 when

Two of the Same: The short stories "A&P" and "Where are you going, Where have you been?"

1125 words - 5 pages anywhere else, and one day, someone might just call you on your bluff, to disastrous consequences.These two women are seemingly innocent, random bystanders picked by older smarter conmen. However, one could easily hold them responsible for their own fates. Not that the victim in a crime is to blame, but, honestly, if you leave your car door open, with the keys inside, and the motor running, while you go inside a store for a few hours, how can you

Macbeth - "Shakespeare's plays tell great stories that still have relevance. How does Shakespeare use dramatic techniques to achieve this?

837 words - 3 pages which two protagonists respond individually and jointly to the psychological burden of their sins. In the course of the play, Macbeth repeatedly misinterprets the guilt that he suffers as being simply a matter of fear. His characteristic way of dealing with his guilt is to face it directly by committing still more misdeeds, and this, of course, only generates further madness.Irony is constantly used in the play. There are two main types of irony

Discuss the ways in which two writers you have studied enhance their stories through the exploration and inclusion of lies, deception and betrayal

926 words - 4 pages when the truth is learnt.The use of lies, deception and betrayal enhances the novel by keeping the reader on his/her toes. It adds to the interest and mystery of the novel. Both Atwood and Marquez use lies, deception and betrayal to form the foundation of their plot. In both novels, lying and betrayal have severe causes, resulting in the death of two characters. In view of the fact that both novels are filled with lies, deception and betrayal, the

In the texts you have studied this year have you found that criminals have received a fair punishment? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

3115 words - 12 pages parent as a sinner is difficult enough for the correct upbringing of Pearl, as a replacement for her father she must seek guidance from God who will be a much better parent for her. However, Hester’s refusal could be regarded as showing her love for the man who committed this crime. This would make her an even greater sinner. The adultery would in that case not at all been excused. It would have seemed that Hester deliberately made love and maybe

A secondary story to Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, i.e. something that could have happend to Sir Gawain on his way to the Green Knight

651 words - 3 pages Camelot's coat of arms, visible in front of his heart.What has seemly been his disaster, comes to bea great help on his missionsince everyone has caught it, but makes his own deduction.The princess, intelligent and remarkably cunning, sees through the knight's idea,prepares to play the gamethat will be her only chance to escape her pre-determined destiny.The foolish dozen of dirt-covered men supposes,on the other hand,to have one of their kind among them

A comparison of Julian in "Everything That Rises Must Converge" and Hulga in "Good COuntry People," two stories by Flannery O'Connor

718 words - 3 pages Flannery O'Connor's two narratives, "Everything That Rises Must Converge" and "Good Country People," are different stories presenting different characters, different plots, and different themes; however, both stories revolve around a mother and her child and their relationship. "Everything That Rises Must Converge" concerns Julian and his mother, and "Good Country People" concerns Hulga and her mother. As the two stories unfold, the similarities

The Old Nurse's Story (E. Gaskell) and The Axe (P. Fitzgerald): Of the two stories you have read, which do you think is the most effective ghost story? Which story do you prefer and why?

2139 words - 9 pages the reader. To be truly frightening the story has to contain a core of credibility and should have a slow build up of tension and mysterious or unexplained events. Lastly, the narrative style of the story is important. The author should think carefully about how it will be told, by whom and why.After reading the two ghost stories The Old Nurse's Story and The Axe, I have found that there are many differences and similarities between them. The Old

Discuss the major steps taken by Hitler from 1933 to 1939 that ultimately led to war. Could Hitler have been prevented from plunging Europe into war? When and how?

646 words - 3 pages fascist policies enabled Germany's rapid rearmament and ensuing military victories.It would be too simple to assign all responsibility for WWII to one man, regardless of popular beliefs about his intentions. Hitler was an enabler; his use of propaganda and the available opportunities nearly gave Germany the domination of Europe it desired. Without those circumstances, however, it is unlikely that Hitler would have experienced the same early success

The institution and I: An article outlining the effect that institutions have on society - Including text "Raw" by Scott Monk and two other texts of my choice

1767 words - 7 pages that final goal; they can see it, but they can't have it. This is just like Brett in 'Raw' he wanted to be like Josh, but couldn't because he could never leave his old habits behind him. This can also be related to Andy in 'Shawshank Redemption', he could see himself outside the prison in New Mexico, but he was restricted by the greed and abuse of human rights. So he chose to break out and reach his goal, even if it was giving the institution a

Similar Essays

The Decision That Could Have Been, Alcoholism

1136 words - 5 pages valley and comments 'and we could have all this,' but she continuesdrinking when she knows well that she carries a child in her womb. She even saysthe alcohol tastes like licorice, that everything tastes the same, and she's gettingtired of her same old life. Surely, she must know the possible damage she can causethe baby to have, but does it stop her from drinking? No, this only indicates that sheis still not ready to change completely. Even

Abortion Should Not Be Illegal. This Is A Persuasive Essay That Shows The Good That Could Come Out Of An Abortion And Why It Should Continue To Be Legal For Women To Choose To Have An Abortion

985 words - 4 pages Abortion, a word you have all heard or said. It is a word that has been in conversations and debates across the country. There is the pro-life side, and the pro-choice side. Abortion is a choice for women, not the government. Women today have the choice of self-determination, to determine whether or not they want to bear children. Religious leaders are trying to abolish the idea of separation of church and state by influencing the government

Adam Smith: A Man So Amazing That He Could Have Invented Fire

756 words - 4 pages they did not employ a single workman, could generally live a year or two upon the stocks which they have already acquired. Many workmen could not subsist a week, few could subsist a month, and scarce any a year without employment. In the long run the workman may be as necessary to his master as his master is to him; but the necessity is not so immediate. (Smith) This means that the ability for some men to work in their own self interest could

To Give Birth To A Child And To Finish A Marathon Race Could Marry The Emotions Of Pain And Joy Together. Pain And Joy Are Two Separate Emotions

735 words - 3 pages To give birth to a child and to finish a marathon race could marry the emotions of pain and joy together. Pain and joy are two separate emotions on the opposite ends of the spectrum. Pain consisted of suffering, agony, and torture. Joy consisted of happiness, delight, and great pleasure. A small amount of women have had the opportunity to experience childbirth and complete a marathon. These women are familiar with the miserable pain that