Managing Resistance To Organizational Change Essay

1962 words - 8 pages

In the course of considering and implementing change, the need frequently arises for effective application of the approaches and tools for managing resistance to change (Palmer, Dunford, & Akin, 2009). Change often fails from ineffective management of the internal and external forces of resistance opposing change (Kotter & Schlesinger, 2008; Oreg, 2003; Palmer et al., 2009). In response, this paper discusses the approaches (tools) deemed most essential for managing resistance to change relative to the scope of the situational contexts in which they might be applied. The discussion centers on considerations for the multidimensional conceptualizations of resistance that are often ignored in evaluating alternatives for taking action.
Multidimensional Conceptualizations of Resistance
Strategies for reducing the negative effects of resistance to change most often fail from an incomplete understanding of the multidimensional nature and scope of resistance (Kotter & Schlesinger, 2008). A more complete understanding of these multidimensional characteristics evolves from considering the meaning of the term. Davidson defines resistance as “. . . anything that workers do which managers do not want them to do, and that workers do not do that managers wish them to do” (Piderit, 2000, p. 785). Thus, in a fundamental sense, the task of resolving problems of resistance to change essentially crystallizes into one of controlling or motivating the dispositional behaviors of employees to facilitate successful outcomes (Gagné & Deci, 2005; Kotter & Schlesinger, 2008). Similarly, Palmer et al., (2009) conceptually define the task of change leadership as one of controlling or shaping behaviors in response to change.
However, the dispositional reactions of employees to change vary widely over multiple dimensions. For example, Piderit (2000) views resistance as being a combination of an individual’s affective (feelings), cognitive (beliefs), and behavioral (actions) reactions to change. According to Piderit (2000), each of these components contributes to an individual’s disposition to resist or support change, which can range along a continuum from strong opposition to ambivalence to strong support. Oreg (2003) characterizes behavioral responses to change in terms of the perceived degrees of fairness of both change outcomes (distributive justice) and the change process (procedural justice), as mediated by differences in personality traits and contextual elements such as self-efficacy, tolerance for change, and social influence.
Further conceptualizations of the multidimensional nature and scope of resistance are captured in goal regulation theory (Meyer, Becker, & Vandenberghe, 2004), which is grounded in theories related to regulatory focus (Higgins, 2002) and self-determination (Deci & Ryan, 2008; Gagné & Deci, 2005). This integrated theory characterizes varying levels and polarity of behavioral responses to change relative to affective, normative, or...

Find Another Essay On Managing Resistance to Organizational Change

Managing Organizational Change Essay

1065 words - 4 pages In this dynamic business environment, change is inevitable. Changes can be planned, or unintentional: depending on the driving forces behind. The major forces for change can be derived from the nature of the workforce, technology, economic shocks, competition, social trends, and world politics (Robbins & Judge, 2011). In this post the author will explain the Kotter’s eight –step approaches to managing organizational change and discuss how his

Managing Organizational Change Essay

2320 words - 9 pages Overview Throughout the history of organizational literature, many scholars have suggested that change initiatives need to originate at the leadership level in order to be successful (Bennis, 1999). However history has shown that the majority of change initiatives fail, especially when mandated by top management (King & Peterson, 2007). This paper will examine why this dichotomy exists, what the role of top management should be in a change

Managing Organizational Change

1015 words - 4 pages to be some type of regular communication between management and the employees. Managers should have an open door policy which enables the employees to feel safe asking questions or having issues addressed.Managers should always prepare for the unexpected. There is no such thing as a perfect plan. No change goes exactly according to plan. Effectively managing changes within an organization requires ongoing reassessments of the willingness and the

Understanding Individual Resistance in Organizational Change

3041 words - 13 pages argued that anything in an individual's environment which poses a threat to their security could be potential source of resistance. In line with this assertion, striving for security is among the reasons for resistance to change. This resistance could be prompted by personal concerns related to the fear of losing a job or a reduction in benefits (Ford 2002). In addition to personal factors, there are also other factors in an organizational that

Answer to Questions Provided for the Managing Organizational Design and Change module

3503 words - 15 pages The aim of this essay assignment is to answer 7 questions provided for the Managing Organisational Design and Change module. This essay will emphasise the overall significance of people management practices in managing successful organisational change. More specifically, the research questions gave us students the opportunity to demonstrate our understanding of the overall module, the ability to think clearly, present, describe, and evaluate our

Managing Organizational Culture for Change

692 words - 3 pages 1) Culture at CMC:Organizational Culture is defined as a pattern of shared basic assumptions that the group learned as it solved its problems of external adaptation and internal integration, that has worked well enough to be considered valid and, therefore, to be taught to every members coming in the organization. In other words, it refers to a system of shared meaning held by the members that distinguishes the organization from other

Resistance to Change

1691 words - 7 pages resistance includes reasons such as: resisting because one doesn't feel involved and the fear of having to learn something new. de Jagar (2001) urges managers to involve employees in the change and create an environment where learning is the norm.On the other hand, irrational resistance exists as well. There are some people for whom no amount or persuasion, evidence, or demonstration is sufficient. They don't want change. Managing these people

Resistance to Planned Change

1097 words - 4 pages impossible, to implement organizational improvements” (Cummings, 2009, p 166). The dimensions of attitude can also be used to assess the potential resistance an organization may face when planning change. Dimensions of Attitudes There are three dimensions of attitudes that are linked to the resistance of change. These three dimensions of attitudes are cognitive, emotional, and intentional. (Piderit, 2000) Each of these dimensions has a

resistance to change

2020 words - 9 pages competitiveness. People are social beings, and it is in human nature to resist change; they are afraid of change whether it is within their personal life, or in the employment setting. Organizational development comes in to try and bridge the gap created between employees and the new strategies. An analytic and critical view about the complexity and ways to overcome resistance to change are the focal points of the essay. Discussion Resistance to change

Management - Handling Resistance to Change

827 words - 3 pages stems largely from the reality or perception of loss, not necessarily from the change initiative itself. Promoting the wisdom of the change, therefore, is unlikely in and of itself to build support. You must also address that sense of loss. That is why the first step in managing resistance is to acknowledge openly what you and others are losing. You might think such candor would only serve to "stir things up," but experience shows that suppressing

An Individuals Resistance to Change

1162 words - 5 pages developments. The organizations watch competitor, supplier, and customer movements. Performance problems and threatening organizational survival can cause issues if failing to do so. This is important when the organization operates regionally. Individual Change. Why it that people is are so resistant of change? Resistance can arise for many reasons many stick out. (Barotol, 2007) Employees dislike change for a number of less logical reasons. Self

Similar Essays

Combatting Resistance To Organizational Change Essay

1537 words - 6 pages what drives resistance can be very powerful in its elimination. There are steps that can be taken to help in the successful implementation and reducing resistance is the most important. Sometimes just having a plan is not enough. It is also important to plan for resistance and develop strategies to deal with its effects. Works Cited Palmer, I., Dunford, R., & Akin, G. (2009) Managing organizational change: A multiple

Combating Resistance To Organizational Change Essay

1376 words - 6 pages Combating Resistance to Organizational Change By any objective measure, the amount of important, frequently distressing, change in organizations has grown enormously over the last two decades (Kotter, 1996). Jeffrey M. Hiatt, CEO of Prosci Inc., (as cited by Gibson, Ivancevich, Donnelly & Konopaske, 2009, p. 481) explained, “thirty years ago, a foturne 100 probably had one or two enterprisewide change intitiatives goiong on; today that number

Resistance To Organizational Change In Business

2685 words - 11 pages . organizations are involved in an extensive organizational change, even though several are believed to be unsuccessful. The process of strategic renewal places new expectations on employees at all levels. Effective organizational change involves adjustments in patterns of employee behavior (Spector, 2010). However, resistance appears to be an inevitable response to change, especially drastic change. There may be many reasons for resistance to change; one

Managing Organizational Change Essay

3310 words - 13 pages Managing Organizational Change{Insert Date}Managing Organizational Change09/03/2002 2AbstractAs the Greek philosopher Heraclitus (525 - 475BC) pointed out: change alone is unchanging. Nowhere is this more true than in corporate North America.Globalization; quantum leaps in technology; mergers and acquisitions; shiftingmarkets and client demands; and, significant changes in the workforce makechanging to survive a strategic imperative. All