Progress Or Setback?: The Implications Of The International Intervention In Libya On The Norms Of The R2 P

3454 words - 14 pages

Introduction

In the 1990s, the international community experienced a loss of more than five million people to warfare, chiefly as a result of internal conflicts (UN, 2000: 43). In the last decade of the 20th century, the debate over humanitarian intervention gained prominence. The question raised—following a series of failures to halt massacres in Rwanda, Somalia and Bosnia and the disputed military intervention in Kosovo without a UN Security Council Resolution—was whether the international community has a right to intervene in the affairs of a sovereign state to protect civilians whose lives are threatened (Evans and Sahnoun, 2002: 100). In 2001, the idea of the responsibility to protect (R2P) was introduced to replace the right of intervention by shifting the language from ‘right’ to ‘responsibility’, which is more helpful in viewing the protection of people positively (Evans and Sahnoun, 2002: 101). Tanguy (2003: 5) states that the world ‘revisit[s] the Pandora's box of intervention’ by recalling the time when the idea was revealed.
Since the report which gave origin to the R2P was first released from the Canadian government-sponsored International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (ICISS) in 2001, there has been a great deal of discussion on R2P. Nearly a decade later, the military intervention in Libya, undertaken by a North Atlantic Treaty Organisation-led (NATO) force after the adoption of two Security Council resolutions, 1970 and 1973, implemented to protect suffering civilians, was considered a pioneering case for the application of R2P (Dembinski and Reinold, 2011: 6-8). The mass killings came to an end with Muammar el-Gaddafi’s death and the subsequent regime change. This event has been proclaimed by some as a ‘triumph for the R2P’ (Thakur, 2011: 23), although others argue that these claims are ‘fables of moral innocence and righteousness’ created by Western society (Rieff, 2011). What was the event all about? Was it a milestone signalling that the international community will never let humanitarian disaster take place? More research needs to be done to investigate the R2P debate further.
The main purpose of this research paper is to analyse how the military intervention in Libya in March 2011 strengthened the R2P norm by illustrating how R2P can be applied, in this case through a series of international attempts to protect Libyan citizens, with a description of theoretical development of R2P itself, and to offer insight into further policy associated with the future R2P debate.

LITERATURE REVIEW: R2P IN DEBATE
There is still space for the R2P discourse, which stemmed from the debate over humanitarian intervention, to be investigated in the scope of normative and practical senses within academic and political arenas. The one main line of debate might be characterised by its normative status, which justifies the use of force against another state’s sovereignty for humanitarian purposes. In particular, the question of...

Find Another Essay On Progress or Setback?: The Implications of the International Intervention in Libya on the Norms of the R2P

the progress of man Essay

854 words - 4 pages keep kingdoms under control. Yehuda Amichai is a poet who experienced firsthand what war really looks like. Upon closely reading several of Yehuda Amichai’s poems a set of motifs develop motifs that paint vivid pictures of human suffering caused by war; motifs that develop into themes of religion and God’s mercy towards the malevolent nature of man. Religion is a big part of Amichai’s poetry it is almost always present in his poems in one form or

China and the Invasion, Implications and Intervention of the Korean War

2844 words - 11 pages Nations infantry en route to establishing a Chinese frontline south of Seoul and across the Han River by January of 1951 . A mere intervention by a poorly equipped Chinese army simply can not constitute their great accomplishment of pushing the "friendly forces" south of the 38th parallel. Thus, through exploring the Soviet influence on China's new Communist regime, identifying China's involvement in the plotting of the June 25th invasion, and by

The Unintended Consequences of Progress in Treatment

760 words - 4 pages . Depending on the level of involvement a person's family has had in helping their loved one manage or work through their symptoms, psycho-education that includes typical projections around progress can be helpful for both the family and the client.

Banning Progress in the World of Swimming

704 words - 3 pages primarily harming themselves because each six-hundred-dollar suit purchased funds the lucrative world of owning swimming organizations which are sponsored by the suit makers. (Speedo, Arena, Blue 70). These concepts all depict the unreasonable nature of the bans.Progress in sports should never be suppressed. Taking away progress is taking away balance which holds the athletic world together. Every athlete is emotionally bonded to his or her piece of

The Implications of Calvinism

1255 words - 5 pages of Calvinism on Dickinson’s poetry and the interpretation of language in her poetry through a Calvinist lens. Specifically, I will focus on the poems that reference “grace” and “election.” History Emily Dickinson was raised in a time in which religion and religious thought was a reality that shaped the everyday interactions of her time. The family and Dickinson attended a Congregationalist church with roots in Puritan or Calvinist doctrine

The Effect of Economic Progress on the Environment

908 words - 4 pages . Ecological system also has been disturbed in some ways. The main culprit behind all these changes is mainly human being. Human being has been using this nature in a wrong a way for his own good. In name of progress he has just destroyed the nature. Especially, industries on the bank of the rivers, deforestation, using animals in a wrong way in business sectors which destroys the balance of ecosystem, are the main causes of the unexpected changes of

International Relations to 1970: Examine the reasons for the United Nations intervention in the Gulf War of 1991. Was this intervention justified?

1698 words - 7 pages invasion of Kuwait challenged the fundamental basis of the UN, "to maintain international peace and security" , thus providing the primary reason for its intervention in the Gulf War. As stated in the UN Charter, the organisation aims to achieve this through the establishment of a structure designed to "take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace, and for the suppression of acts of aggression or other

The Pursuit of Human Progress

2062 words - 9 pages people in textbooks is realized. Many figures praised by Americans do not deserve all the credit they receive without receiving the blame for the wrongs they had done. History at different school levels is taught in different ways and often with different facts. The cause of the American Civil War could be different depending on which school or geographic region a student is in. In elementary school many children were taught that it all

The Struggle for Freedom in Libya

1751 words - 8 pages help Libya(oil maybe?). Specifically a unipolar superpower like the US. They didn’t help in Tunisia or Egypt, why Libya in particular? During the revolution, NATO backed the Libyan rebels and cause them to win vey battles during the civil war. US made a promise to continue to help Libya in its’ pursuit of democracy, but it looks as though Libya is going to have to figure this part of it fate on its own as most countries are staying away at the moment. But when the economy is up and running, and oil production is back at its peaks, What will the international system look like for Libya then? ELABORATE SOCIAL MEDIA

Where Are the human rights in Libya?

1021 words - 5 pages cannot do with Sharia law. For example, you cannot marry outside of Muslim, you cannot become any religion outside of Muslim, and you cannot push people away from Islam (Billion bibles 2013). I do not even believe that there can be secular rights in Libya. The rules of Islam guarantees everyone cannot be equal since you only get rights when you have full legal status or when you are a spiritual being. Secular law guarantees that everyone is equal

The Implications of Expressed Emotion in Schizophrenia

1936 words - 8 pages illness of the dependent (Whittick, 1993). When a Schizophrenic patient goes into convalescence, they are required to be in a stable environment which is low in expressed emotion, otherwise implications, including relapse, are more likely to occur (Vaughn and Leff, 1976). Schizophrenia is a complex psychological disorder in which the sufferer experiences severe disturbances is cognitive ability, speech, perception, emotion and behaviour (Herz and

Similar Essays

The Us In Libya Essay

2216 words - 9 pages and removing Libya from the Human Rights Counsel, but recently the United States began firing missiles at Libyan tanks and other military weapons. Did the United States go too far this time? Experts of United States’ Foreign Policy feel that President Obama’s actions, or what is being called the “Obama Doctrine” may have crossed a line with his hasty decision to use military force. Experts of United States’ International Relations fear a decline in

The Power Of Norms Essay

718 words - 3 pages member of society breaks that norm they may be looked at as strange or even penalized depending on what kind of norm is broken. Norms are broken into three categories which are folkways, mores, and laws. Folkways are customs or desirable behaviors that are not strictly enforced. Violating a folkway is not criminal, but violating a folkway may have you looked at as weird. Mores are the strongest form of norms they have great moral significance in a

Geography: Violence And Poverty In The History Of Libya

1284 words - 5 pages Italy, United Kingdom, and France. Libya became an independent nation on 24 December 1951. Most of Libya is considered a third world country. Currently the population in Libya is around 6.7 million people. Early in the history of Libya, it was part of the Roman Empire. When the Roman Kingdom divided into two, Libya became part of Eastern Roman Empire. In 642 Libya was conquered by the Arabs. During the 16th century, Libya became part

The Duty Of Assistance Or Humanitarian Intervention

1116 words - 5 pages hope or expectation that liberal states step up to the task of humanitarian intervention would be better for the purposes of distributive justice in the international system. This way, a state cannot be punished for not fulfilling that duty to assist. Forcing a state to choose a course of action based on the possible consequences that come with not choosing that path removes a state’s ability to be self-determining in the international system