Should Hate Speech Be Regulated On Campus?

1229 words - 5 pages

Johnathan Rauch would not be in favor of the speech codes proposed at ISU because he argues that racist speech cannot be regulated without political and all other speech also falling victim to censorship. In Rauch's view the question is not which speech or expressive behavior is acceptable or is not acceptable because if any is restricted all speech is in jeopardy. Rauch would use two different schools of thought to explain his views on hate speech, the first being "purism".The use of speech codes is an example of purism, because they want to stamp out racism. According to Rauch, purists believe that all racist speech should not be allowed and eliminating prejudice is the ultimate goal. He thinks that there is no possible chance of this happening so, we as a society should make the best of it and tolerate and learn from prejudice. He also describes purists as totalists, who see racism as harmful and blame words rather than people. Just because minorities are being discriminated against doesn't mean that a political correctness movement will eliminate where prejudice is founded. Rauch really believes that this approach is unrealistic and inefficient.The view that Rauch would take is that of an "intellectual pluralists". Intellectual pluralism advocates the exchange of ideas; even if those particular ideas are sometimes bigoted. The first Amendment is considered more important to him than the 14th Amendment because it promotes liberty over equality. Any action or law that limits an individuals liberty is destructive to America as a whole. He and his fellow libertarians accept racism and think that it is not necessary to prosecute people solely on racist speech or expressions. Rauch acknowledges that there is discrimination and prejudice but he would argue that speech codes on college campuses are not the answer. He would definitely not agree that the University could discipline a student "for a discriminatory comments, epithets or for other expressive behavior…". Purists think that this speech is "hateful" or "violent", but Rauch would say that even though that speech may evoke fear, restricting it does nothing for actual violence.Another point that Rauch makes is that it is sometimes difficult to distinguish a difference between prejudice and plain old American ignorance. Rauch does not want to draw a line but with speech codes one must be drawn somewhere and at that point it will be very hazy. He says that the line between a racist belief and simply controversial one is a vague one, which should not be determined by school administrators.On the other hand, Charles A. Lawrence would agree with the implementation of speech codes at ISU. He was also an avid supporter of the codes proposed at Stanford where he taught. As a supporter of the 14th Amendment to ensure equality among Americans, he feels that due to the increasing number of racial incident on college campuses regulations on hate speech is justified. Lawrence thinks that it is very...

Find Another Essay On Should Hate Speech be Regulated on Campus?

Guns Should Be Regulated Essay

1052 words - 5 pages Regulate Guns In the United States, we will let almost anyone purchase a gun. We need to regulate these dangerous weapons and provide a safer environment for our citizens. There has been a debate in our government for a long time concerning how and when guns should be regulated. It seems that most people who are against gun control do not care or do not understand that regulating guns is a necessity for safety. If guns were more regulated we

Should Healthcare Assistants be Regulated? Essay

1482 words - 6 pages has had appropriate training and whom they deem competent to perform the task … they must be assured that the person to whom they have delegated (the delegatee) fully understands the nature of the delegated task … The delegatee should know their limitations and when to seek advice from the appropriate professional in the event that circumstances change’ (NMC, 2013) This guidance is not sufficiently robust. For example; if a HCA states that they

Marijuana Should Be Legalized and Regulated

2068 words - 9 pages them. In a truly free society substances such as marijuana should not be illegal. The prohibition of alcohol had shown that it is impossible to change people’s habits, so instead of fighting it, it is better to profit from it. The prohibition of marijuana was a mistake based on racism and politics, cannabis also has widespread use in America and the country can greatly benefit by legalizing it; therefore, U.S Federal Government needs to legalize

Human Cloning Should Not Be Regulated

1084 words - 4 pages these breakthroughs in their sights, would be forced to take their experiments underground to avoid political repercussions.           The opposition insists on the regulation of cloning and is suggesting a permanent ban, arguing that cloning in any way is unethical.  Some take the position that scientists can not be trusted, ethically, to know when the experiments should stop, therefore, the scientific community would be unable to effectively

Hate Speech on College Campuses

563 words - 2 pages to punish a racist speaker, but instead on the depthof its commitment to the principles of equality and education. Many universities, underpressure to respond to the concerns of those who are the objects of hate, have adoptedcodes or policies prohibiting speech that offends any group based on race, gender,ethnicity, religion or sexual orientation.That's the wrong response, well-meaning or not. The First Amendment to theUnited States Constitution

Animal testing is unethical and should be regulated

1255 words - 5 pages Animal testing is unethical and should be regulated.In the present era of science and technology, animals are used for experiments in various domains such as cosmetic testing, education, biomedical research and so on. Educational institutes from all over the world use animals in biomedical testing; cosmetic and genetic industries primarily use animals for different types of tests. Sarah Rose A. Miller, who wrote the prize-winning essay for the

Designing Babies Is Beneficial and Should Be Regulated

1063 words - 5 pages your child and prevent them from hereditary diabetes. There are countless situations like this genetic engineering can fix. Thus, designing babies is beneficial and should be regulated. People have the right to genetically engineer their children so it should not be banned. Jeffrey Kahn, a bioethicist, says that parents will someday test genes to give their children preferable traits like intelligence,strong immune systems, and string muscles

On the Issue of Hate Speech

1527 words - 7 pages criticizing the national draft. He was arrested, and the Supreme Court decided that his arrest was acceptable because his actions posed 'clear and present danger'. Other limits exist on libel and slander. Now, with these limits enacted in the past, and with a growing multicultural society in America, a debate on a certain issue has slowly increased. Should hate speech be protected as free speech, or should it be suppressed? Hate speech is defined as "an

Offensive Speech Should be Allowed

2716 words - 11 pages implementing speech codes into campus legal systems in order to control such displays. However, this is an inadequate and superficial response to a much deeper issue. College campuses should not regulate hate speech because such regulations violate our constitutional rights, no practical definition of hate speech exists, and there is no way to enforce punishment. Abridging freedom of speech on college campuses bandages the internal wound caused by racism

Symbolic Speech Should Be Protected

2721 words - 11 pages Why Symbolic Speech Should Be Protected 1. The measure of a great society is the ability of its citizens to tolerate the viewpoints of those with whom they disagree. As Voltaire once said, “I may disagree with what you have to say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it” (Columbia). This right to express one's opinion can be characterized as “freedom of speech.” The concept of “freedom of speech” is a Constitutional

"Parking At The REC Center" Teacher Comments: Work On Justification Part Of Paper. Grad: 80% Paper About Why Parking Should Be More Regulated At The Gym

1190 words - 5 pages very likely to get a ticket for doing this. I believe the people who should be receiving the tickets are those who park in the REC parking lot while not using the facility.As the year goes on and people start becoming more lazy and tired of walking, I think that this problem gets even worse. The REC parking lot is closer to the Living Learning Center (LLC) and even the tower, which are two of the places to live on campus. I think that many of the

Similar Essays

Should Hate Speech Be Regulated?

1840 words - 8 pages regulated or if it should be regulated. It is hate speech. What exactly is hate speech? Hate speech is when a person uses words intentionally to hurt someone else; they can use hateful words based on race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation (dictionary.com). Yet the origin of hate-speech laws has been largely forgotten. The divergence between the United States and European countries is of comparatively recent origin. In fact, the United

We Must Put And End To Hate Speech On Campus

3903 words - 16 pages or expression. (FIRE, What Are Speech Codes?, para. 1). While everyone can essentially agree on the definition of a speech code, the problem arises when people are asked what the speech code is attempting to regulate. Some are of the mindset that hate speech is just that – speech, and nothing more. Others believe it can be identified by intent, while a third group looks at the underlying meaning behind the speech. These differing viewpoints

Should Hate Groups Be Allowed Free Speech?

927 words - 4 pages allows all citizens the freedom to express any and all opinions, no matter how offensive and hurtful. This leads many to question whether these hate groups should be allowed the right to free speech. I believe that hate groups should be allowed free speech because all Americans have the right of free speech, it is not discriminatory unless it incites violence, and hate can be prevented through education rather than criminalization. Hate groups are

Pornography Should Be Regulated Essay

2343 words - 9 pages When deliberating over whether access to pornography should be prohibited, four areas of contention must be elaborated upon and evaluated critically to provide a sensible basis on which a judgement can be made. Firstly, it must be concluded whether pornography can be classed as a form of speech, and whether it enjoys the same protections as art and literature under the principle. Secondly, works such as those of Catherine MacKinnon can be