Skeptic Approach To Socrates' Knowledge About Knowledge

1513 words - 6 pages

In Plato's Republic Book V lines 476d to 478e, Plato's main characters Socrates and Glaucon have an interesting discussion about epistemology. The argument in this passage serves to prove that knowledge and opinion are not the same. This argument is based on the premise that knowledge is set over the complete existence of things, whereas opinion is set over "intermediate" existence of things. In this paper, I will first divide the completeness into two categories, that is, mathematical and moral. Then I will contend that mathematical completeness can be achieved, thus known, yet moral completeness is impossible, thus one is bound to opine about moral issues. To substantiate, I will focus on the Form of Justice. I will argue that it is doubtful whether one can know the Form of Justice, since justice does not exist completely, but in contexts that vary. Hence, if justice does not exist completely, due to its lacking Form, then Socrates' main argument loses its soundness, because it is based on the premise that knowledge and Forms apply to everything, which inevitably include knowledge of justice as well.Socrates' argument starts with the distinction of two types of people regarding their power to think, one's thoughts being opinions and the other's knowledge (476d). What distinguishes these two groups of people, Socrates argues, is their differing ability to see the world (476). The ones who opine can only see what the thing is like (participants), whereas the ones who know can see the thing itself (Form) as well. Socrates declares his first premise in line 477a: "what is completely is completely knowable and what is no way is in every way unknowable". Consequently, he points out the premise that knowledge is assigned to what is, or to elaborate what exists, and ignorance is assigned to what does not exist. Connecting these two premises, one comes to the condition that to be known, things should exist completely. At this point, Socrates' aforementioned argument must be recalled, which states that there are participants of the things and the thing (Form) itself (476c-d). Since participants exist in the opining person's mind, but Forms don't, Socrates argues that those who are capable of seeing one half of the reality could only be considered as having half of the complete knowledge, the "intermediate". He concludes that opinion and knowledge are set over different things and have different functions, thereby having different powers (477c-d). In short, knowledge is an infallible power and opinion fallible, as knowledge is based on Forms which are stable; yet opinion only on the Form's participants which are ever-changing.It is noteworthy that in his argument, Socrates makes a full correlation between knowledge of Forms and knowledge in general. So there are two necessary preconditions to know. Firstly, the Forms should exist, and secondly, Forms should be knowable. Only if both of these preconditions are true, one could assert to have knowledge,...

Find Another Essay On Skeptic Approach to Socrates' Knowledge about Knowledge

Plato's "trial and death of socrates", Explains socrates view of self-examination (meditation) as the path to knowledge

897 words - 4 pages Knowledge as Self-ExaminationSocrates had an important point to make when he said," I do not think I know what I do not know." This was the reason why Socrates believed himself wiser than the wise men of Athens. This was the only reason Socrates was wiser than the other men considered wise in Athens. Socrates knew he didn't know something if he had no knowledge of it; where as, the men considered wise thought that they knew something when in


4088 words - 17 pages demand for knowledge-driven employees or knowledge-workers.Organization knowledge capital (tacit and explicit) must be managed. Knowledge management is not about building a computerized systems of human capital but it is about the planning and implementation of activities designed to continuously identify, acquire, apply, share, develop, create, preserve and audit(measure) organization knowledge assets. Knowledge management is about sharing best

About A Boy: Self Knowledge

599 words - 2 pages The novel About A Boy, by Nick Hornby, depicts the life of a social outcast named Marcus, who is sheltered from the outside world by his mother, and is just trying to be accepted by society. While on the path to achieving this goal, Marcus obtains a newly found self knowledge, within himself, as a direct result of the obstacles and conflicts he faces. There are many obstacles which exemplify how Marcus obtains self knowledge about himself; one

A Knowledge -based Approach to Innovation An Application for Project- based Firms

1055 words - 4 pages unit is individualistic in nature and has self seeking interest. A PBO is concerned with coordination of individual projects, and coordination of subcontractors and their suppliers#Characteristic of Knowledge ResourcesFrom research, it is observed that clients, projects, suppliers and government institutions are the main source of innovation in a project-based industry. But little research is done about the way the knowledge is transferred and to

This is about the greek tragidy Oedipus. Includes quotes. About one of the themes From ingorance to knowledge

507 words - 2 pages From Ignorance to KnowledgeIn the Greek Tragedy Oedipus, Oedipus moves closer to knowledge and truth as each scene progresses, but something distracts him from it. Each scene advances his search and delays his discovery. In the end he finally realizes his blindness, and he greatly punishes himself for is actions. This is just one of the three themes in the Greek Tragedy.In scene one the oracle Teiresias, who has just seen the god Apollo, meets

The Lack of General Knowledge about Mental Illness

1410 words - 6 pages The Lack of General Knowledge about Mental Illness In our world today, we have a generally poor understanding of mental illness in two distinct ways: we don´t understand the dangers that mental illness can present to people as they go about their everyday lives, and we don´t understand how to properly care for people that suffer from mental illness. However, if we better understand when, why, and how mentally ill people can become violent, and

The Knowledge About Race and The Whiteness Theory

1387 words - 6 pages history classes and none them talked about African American history before slavery. Once I did research on African American history from articles, to books, and to documentaries I wondered why none of this was taught to students or shared with the world. I would to explain and describe a theory called “political whiteness” and gave details on why I believe that it is a big part of why African Americans don’t know their own history. Whiteness theory

What are the differences between knowledge and Belief? How do these apply to claims about existence of objects?

1361 words - 5 pages To most, knowledge is what we 'know' through learning and general knowledge. But to sit down and explore the idea of knowledge and the idea of belief brings up some philosophical questions; what is knowledge? If it is what we have learnt, how do we know it is definite, if it is scientifically proven, then is it science that navigates and has the final say in what can be classed as 'knowledge?' Belief is what we have all been told, since

Comparison and conclusions about the nature of knowledge between knowing a friend and knowing how to swim, knowing a scientific theory and knowing a historical period

1037 words - 4 pages your knowledge about another person can determine if he is good or bad. For example you know a person who wants to be your friend but you also know that he has been cruel in the past so you reason that he will be cruel to you also and not want him as a friend.Scientific theories must be proven also. Scientific theories cannot be made up or pulled out of thin air. We also see in comparing knowing a friend and proving scientific theories that

Investigating Students' Intuitive Knowledge About Patterns That Are Discussed in the Science Classroom

1754 words - 7 pages . In this paper I will attempt to understand in detail the relationship between the content and form of students’ generated causal explanations. The data presented in this paper was collected from an extra-curriculum summer course conducted in order to investigate students’ intuitive knowledge about patterns that are discussed in the science classroom and which occur in the everyday world (e.g. equilibration, oscillation, chaos, etc.). The two

Knowledge: Attitudes about Aging and Aging Anxiety by By Linda J. Allan and James A. Johnson

1926 words - 8 pages Knowledge UNDERGRADUATE ATTITUDES TOWARD THE ELDERLY: THE ROLE OF KNOWLEDGE, CONTACT AND AGING ANXIETY. By Linda J. Allan and James A. Johnson The aim of the study was to examine the relationship between attitudes about aging and aging anxiety. The focus of the study was to determine the role that aging anxiety plays a mediator between experiences. The experiences focused on were in the form of factual knowledge and contact with the elderly

Similar Essays

The Building Blocks Approach To Knowledge Management

1019 words - 5 pages strategy, e.g. customer satisfaction. The measured results have to be interpreted in order to evaluate the success of the knowledge management tasks and to compare the results to the goals of knowledge management that were set. The evaluation is the basis for the adjustment of the further goals. The building block approach provides a comprehensive concept for the systematic han-dling of knowledge. Most influencing factors could be considered within

How Dose Socrates Prove “Virtue Is Knowledge”

1030 words - 4 pages question “is virtue knowledge?” In my opinion, Socrates’s understanding of knowledge and virtue, are all the knowledge about goodness, which are truth and universal. And from his point of view, all knowledge are something we already have in our souls. The meaning of learning is recollection and self-understanding. So what Socrates teaches is not indoctrinating knowledge from outside to someone, but to inspire and guide others to understand themselves and acquire something they already have. This means some virtue do not need others to inspire and guide to be gained, they can also be received by self-understanding and self-thinking, so there is no so called “teacher”.

“A Skeptic Is One Willing To Question Any Knowledge Claim, Asking For Clarity In Definition, Consistency In Logic, And Adequacy Of Evidence” (Adapted

1570 words - 7 pages Knowledge comprises of how an individual thinks, which can be influenced by his/her experience, observation, or what has been taught to him/her. A skeptic is said to be someone who questions knowledge, by asking for clear definition, consistency, or evidence. When I am studying for my exam, when I don’t understand something, I question the definition, consistency, and evidences in order to fully understand what I’m learning, does this make me a

Essay Title 6:“A Skeptic Is One Who Is Willing To Question Any Knowledge Claim, Asking For Clarity In Definition, Consistency In Logic And Adequac

649 words - 3 pages What is skepticism? It refers to a doubt, about any knowledge claim when it is not clear to one about any fact and when evidences are less to any knowledge claim. Definition of skepticism is generally any questioning attitude knowledge, facts or opinions/beliefs stated as fact or doubt regarding claims that are taken for granted elsewhere. Skepticism occurs only when the information is not adequate, clarity of material is not there i.e. of two