The Arguements For And Against The Use Of Animals

2228 words - 9 pages

The debate regarding the use of animals in experiments has come under increasing public and political attention throughout the 1980?s and 1990?s. Many objections have been raised against the once accepted scientific procedures by all sectors of society. There are many arguments for and against the use of animals in scientific experimentation most of which revolve around both practical and ethical issues.There are many arguments, which support the use of animals in experiments. According to Cardwell (1996) animals are studied simply because they are fascinating to study, they can be used in research where humans can't due to the restrictions placed on human research by the BPS guidelines, variables can be controlled precisely when using animals and as they have a short lifespan their development and offspring can be observed; several generations can be bred in a short period of time which is particularly useful in studying genetic characteristics (Coolican, 1994).Those against animal experimentation however, would argue that the animals suffer during research. This has resulted in two fundamental questions arising. Firstly, the question of whether animals can feel pain and so indeed suffer, and secondly, whether anything can justify the animals? subjection to any suffering.Descartes in 1637 pronounced that non-human animals were like machines. They had no thoughts and feelings. Descartes considered animals "thoughtless brutes", automata or machines. Fontaine wrote in 1738: "They said the animals were clocks; that the cries they emitted when struck were only the noise of a little spring that had been touched but that the whole body was without feeling...they made fun of those who pitied the creatures as if they felt pain.? (in Rachels, James 1990) Descartes later modified his ideas to believe that animals are conscious of some things, such as hunger and pain, but he maintained that animals do not have thoughts about what they are aware of. Darwin (1859) repudiated Descartes view that animals cannot feel or think. Darwin (1872) showed similarities between humans and apes, for example, the capacity for pleasure, pain, curiosity, grief, fear, devotion, anger, joy, love and patience. Darwin noticed that animals have a nervous system and bodily organ systems like humans and so feel pain like humans.Biologists now know that animals have complex psychological states. They can experience pain, distress discomfort anxiety fear especially with strangers. Animals have self-preservation as a motive for life; they have alarm systems to predators. They are never willing to die to feed man. Animals however are incapable of speech and so cannot communicate directly how they feel to man, but neither can children or the intellectually disturbed yet we do not consider that we have the right to use them in experiments.In addition, Evolution Theory states that man and animals evolved from simpler life forms, that man evolved from an animal form and is related to the...

Find Another Essay On THE ARGUEMENTS FOR AND AGAINST THE USE OF ANIMALS

Costello's Argument Against the Slaughter of Animals

807 words - 3 pages regenerating, and bringing rabbits, rats, and poultry live stock ceaselessly into the world for the purpose of killing them.” Here she comments on the actions of human exploitation, illustrating how the treatment of Jews by the Third Reich is relative to the slaughter of animals by humans. During the final part of Costello`s visit to Appleton, Elizabeth Costello makes another analogy between the slaughter of animals and the treatment of Jews in the

The Presentation of Socrates' Arguements in Plato’s Apology and Crito

967 words - 4 pages sure that his sons grow up in the right way and praises some of the jurors who voted for his innocence. In Plato’s Crito Socrates argues that it would be wrong for him to escape from prison. Speaking to his friend Cirto, Socrates explains that escaping from prison would go against many of his beliefs. Socrates believes in seeking the truth, not repaying a wrong with another wrong, and obeying the laws of the state. He also states that escaping

Write an article arguing for or against the use of mobile phones and technology in schools

815 words - 3 pages Nowadays science and Technology has been advance and develop also. We are now living in a modern society, in which the standard of our living is improving day by day. The use of modern technology has become an essential part of our life. Nowadays the mobile phones have also become an essential part of our life because everywhere the people are using it for e.g. even the students are also using them in their daily life. The students are using

Experimental evidence FOR and AGAINST the immediate use of contextual information during syntactic ambiguity resolution.

1488 words - 6 pages one, the referential context did not consistently influenced participants’ disambiguation preferences. In contrast, prepositional phrases in a VP-supporting context condition were normally computed faster than those in an NP context fashion, and NP attachment stimulated shorter mean reading times than VP attachment in both context conditions. Other findings also advocate for the use of discourse-based information in subsequent stages of

The Use of Animals in Research

808 words - 3 pages In March 1980, there emerged a group called PETA, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. This group, founded by Alex Pacheco and Ingrid Newkirk, fights against the use of animals for research. PETA became a well known name between 1981 and 1990 when they went up against IBR, Institute for Behavioral Research. In the book Monkey Business, the story is told of the ten year battle between PETA and IBR. “Through it all, the Silver Spring

The Use of Animals in Medical Research

993 words - 4 pages addiction, and senility.Animal rights advocates challenge the use of animals in research, arguing that besides being inhumane, it is unnecessary. In addition, they claim that laboratory animals are abused.Critics of animal experimentation question whether animals are really needed for medical research. They point to the many alternative methodologies that have been developed and question whether animal experimentation has provided any benefits that

The use of animals in medical research

665 words - 3 pages such as the Guinea Pig, which contributed to 23 Nobel Prizes for medicines in discovery of Vitamin C, the tuberculosis bacterium and adrenaline as well as many other diseases and infections. There are no specific references in the Bible, which state anything about animal testing. However, Christians are usually in agreement about the use of animals in medical research. One could possibly interpret from the Creation (Gensis:1) `Rule over the fish

Animal Testing and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals

1307 words - 5 pages some medicines would be cheaper and more reliable to humans. How ethical is animal testing compared to other methods of testing products for humane medical use? Today a lot of people are just looking for the most effective product out there to use. If animals aren’t used for testing products, consumers are more likely to buy these products. Humans are more at risk for side effects because animals don’t always get accurate results. Animals and

Animal cruelty- This case is against the abuse of animals

1749 words - 7 pages trouble with search alternatives, 450-600 in review of painful procedures, and 350 to 400 with monitoring for compliance." (USDA 2000)Within those estimated 1600 facilities across the U.S. who do not follow IACUC's protocol for animal testing, and with IACUC inspections happening once a year, the agency has little control on how animals are being treated.Each year, scientists use two million animals for experiments and research; furthermore, 100,000

Use and misuse of animals

1757 words - 7 pages Before we as a society can decide whether animals have rights or not, we need to keep an open mind. Evolution of life is at least 25 million years old, and from the beginning right to the present day humans have fought for the survival against other species and have evolved to such an extent that they have been taken as the most superior of all living beings. Both Cohen and Williams value human life. They feel if the betterment of humanity is

The Use Animals to Show the Main Themes in Of Mice and Men

1273 words - 5 pages all the themes in “Of Mice and Men”. He has a key character that represents a animal in many ways (Lennie), he has people that are treated like animals, he shows how the American dream for ranch people is to have a farm with many animals, he lets the senses of the animals predict or illustrate and display emotions of the events that will occur or will have occurred, he makes the animals show foreshadowing and he shows how the animals were treated at the time. These are all the main points that I have discussed in this essay to answer the question “how does Steinbeck use animals to show the main themes in “Of Mice and Men?”.

Similar Essays

Outline The Case For And Against The Use Of Referenda

2362 words - 9 pages OUTLINE THE CASE FOR AND AGAINST REFERENDAThe concept of referenda has existed for hundreds of years, coming into official use towards the end of the 19th century. There is evidence that the 'poll of the people' was used by William the Conqueror and by the Vatican in medieval times to affirm leaderships. Tacitus in 'Germania' suggests that Principes should decide minor questions, but great matters should be decided by the people. This idea

The Military Use Of Animals Essay

1185 words - 5 pages animals has also caused much controversy. On land dogs, goats and many other animals sniff out and detect bombs. In the water seals, dolphins, and some other animals detect and retrieve bombs (Story 1). This marine use is especially important and safer for animals due to the make and purpose of these underwater bombs. These marine uses actually go back to 1960. It started as a study of these marine animals and ended up discovering that these

The Validity Of The Cosmological, Ontological, And Teleological Arguements

1331 words - 5 pages The topic I will be discussing in this essay is whether or not the ontological, the cosmological, or the teleological arguements provide sufficient evidence to prove the existence of the Supreme Personal Being. All three arguements have points for and against them, but whether they prove the existence of God (from here on out taken to mean the Supreme Personal Being) or not remains still to be a topic of debate.The weakest of the three

Discuss And Evaluate The Arguments For And Against The Use Of The Death Penalty.

3024 words - 12 pages Discuss and evaluate the arguments for and against the use of the death penalty.Capital punishment is "the infliction of death as punishment for certain crimes" (dictionary online). In the Bible itself it prescribes death for crimes such as murder, kidnapping, witchcraft and many more. By 1500, in England, only foremost felonies conceded the death penalty - murder, larceny, burglary, rape, arson and treason. However, from 1723 under the "Waltham