The Case For Euthanasia, Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legalized?

1534 words - 6 pages

Throughout the twentieth century, major scientific and medical advances have greatly enhanced the life expectancy of the average person. However, there are many instances where doctors can preserve life artificially. In these cases where the patient suffers from a terminal disease or remains in a 'persistent vegetative state' or PVS from which they cannot voice their wishes for continuation or termination of life, the question becomes whether or not the patient has the freedom to choose whether or not to prolong their life even though it may consist of pain and suffering. In answer to this question, proponents of physician-assisted suicide, most notably, Dr. Jack Kevorkian, are of the opinion that not only should patients be able to abstain from treatment, but if they have a terminal and/or extremely painful condition, they should be able to seek out the assistance of a doctor in order to expedite their death with as little pain as possible.Contained herein are the arguments for and against the legalization of doctor-assisted suicide, as well as where the state courts stand in respect to this most delicate of issues.In the hopes of clarification, we must first distinguish between active and passive euthanasia. Passive euthanasia involves the patient's refusal of medical assistance. It involves the right to die which is protected by the United States Constitution clauses of due process liberty and the right to privacy (Fourteenth Amendment). The right to doctor-assisted suicide, or active euthanasia, consists of, '...a patient's right to authorize a physician to perform an act that intentionally results in the patient's death, without the physician's being held civilly or criminally liable for having caused the death' .The 'passive' form of euthanasia was first deemed legal by the New Jersey State Supreme Court in 1976 In re Quinlan . In the Quinlan case, the court allowed a competent patient to terminate the use of life-sustaining medical machines to prolong life. Since New Jersey's decision, all fifty states have enacted similar statutes which contain living will provisions. However, although the United States Supreme Court upheld the Quinlan decision in re Cruzan , it changed the parameters of passive euthanasia . With the Cruzan decision, the Supreme Court held that passive euthanasia was legal but only for competent adults or those who are incompetent but have previously procured a living will. However, if the patient is without a living will and incompetent, it becomes the burden of the family to prove that there is 'clear and convincing evidence' to the affect that the patient does not want to continue living in a vegetative state.As to active euthanasia, there has been no Supreme Court ruling determining whether the right to die, as understood in passive euthanasia cases, can be bound over to active euthanasia. The decision is thus left to the individual states. Currently, thirty-one states have criminalized explicitly the act of assisted...

Find Another Essay On The Case for Euthanasia, Should Physician-Assisted Suicide be Legalized?

Should Assisted Suicide Be Legalized? Essay

738 words - 3 pages situation, some patients aren’t capable of putting an end to their suffering on their own. They require the assistance of a doctor. A paralyzed patient, for example, may not be able to put an end to their life alone. Currently, only three states have legalized physician-assisted suicide (euthanasia.procon). This clearly is not fair and needs to change. Medical assistance should be offered nationally to those who are looking to end their suffering, with

Should Physician-Assisted Death be Legalized in the United States

658 words - 3 pages Radical assumptions have been made on whether or not physician-assisted death should be legalized in the United States because of its citizens’ uncertainty about this delicate subject. Physician-assisted suicide is the method by which an individual is provided with the drugs or equipment needed to commit suicide. The terms “aid in dying” or “death with dignity” are preferred over “suicide” due to their distinction from "suicide," where assisted

Should Physician-assisted Suicide Be Legal?

1717 words - 7 pages Should physician-assisted suicide be legal? This debated subject has no right or wrong answer. Assisting someone in death has a felony murder conviction in some cases. There are a few different ways of being charged, but there are certain circumstances. There are many reasons why I am for it and of course, I have reasons against it. When you have a loved one in a vegetative state, does the family say yes or no to “pulling the plug

Assisted Suicide Should Not be Legalized

1878 words - 8 pages techniques can provide substantial relief for up to 95 percent of the patients treated (“Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide 11).These are the types of remedies that people should be looking at to help them though their pain instead of turning to assisted suicide. Many people who are going through rough times just want to take the “easy” way out of their suffering. Assisted suicide offers an attractive “solution” for avoiding the burdens

Doctor-Assisted Suicide Should Not be Legalized?

954 words - 4 pages , friends will bring joy into your life. Works Cited Somerville, M. (2003). Should doctor-assisted suicide be legalized for the terminal ill?. Somerville, M. (2003). Should doctor-assisted suicide be legalized for the terminal ill?. Somerville, M. (2003). Should doctor-assisted suicide be legalized for the terminal ill?. (2004, June 1). Medicine Net Corporation. Retrieved October 17, 2010 from Medterms: http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=32841

Physician Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

799 words - 4 pages Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS) and euthanasia raise ethical questions about the medicalisation of death (J Hardwig, 2006; Kavanaugh, 2000) and whether it is worse to kill a patient, or to let them die through omission of treatment (Kavanaugh, 2000). All have the same outcome – the death of the patient – the ethical dilemma arise when considering how the patient’s death occurred (Rachels, 1975). Allowing a patient to die from the cessation of

A Case for the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide

1379 words - 6 pages doses of morphine to my grandfather. It was their hope that the morphine would not only ease his pain, but also end his life. On March 16, 2010, my grandfather died. Due to the undignified and inhumane manner in which my grandfather spent his last months on this earth, I believe the right to choose physician-assisted suicide to end one's life should be legal for those who have a terminal illness. As a nation, we have vehemently deliberated the

Physician Assisted Suicide Should Or Should Not Be

745 words - 3 pages Euthanasia generally refers to hastening death for a merciful motive or a "good death". Passive euthanasia includes forgoing life support or extraordinary treatments. Active euthanasia, also called mercy killing, involves direct interventions to hasten death. The highly controversial forms active euthanasia is physician assisted suicide (PAS). Physician assisted suicide occurs when the means is provided for a patient to bring on death by someone

Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide: Nice Words for Murder

2074 words - 8 pages of the elderly and "incompetent," and anyone else considered to be a burden to society. The reflections in this essay are intended to wake us up to the main issues involved in the euthanasia debate. Consider the Nancy Cruzan case. She had been in a coma for almost eight years, but was NOT dying, NOT deteriorating. The courts allowed food and water to be discontinued, and 12 days later (on the day after Christmas) she died. Note well, she did

Should Physician-Assisted Suicide be Legal in America?

886 words - 4 pages , physician-assisted suicide should be legal but it needs to be heavily regulated, and lastly, just no. The first position I am going to talk about is yes, physician-assisted suicide should legal, but it depends on the illness. For example, physician-assisted suicide should not be accessible to a patient who has depression because depression for the most part is treatable. Further, physician-assisted suicide should not only be for those who are

Euthanasia Essay - The Immorality of Physician Assisted Suicide

1121 words - 4 pages States, Physician Assisted Suicide or PAS is illegal in all states except for Oregon.  If PAS were to be legalized in the rest of the country, it would cause major problems.  In the one state that Physician Assisted Suicide is legal there have been major problems and any unhappy people.  Mentally ill patients have been stereotyped as crazy people who have to be locked away so they don't hurt themselves or anyone else.  This is a reality only

Similar Essays

Euthanasia/Physician Assisted Suicide Should Not Be Legalized

1510 words - 6 pages forget how euthanasia murdered that beloved man, my grandfather. Euthanasia/Physician assisted suicide should not be legalized in the United States. The definition of murder is “killing intentionally and with premeditation”, how is euthanasia any different? (Miller) Not only is it morally wrong, but logically and ethically as well. Human life is not anyone’s to take and destroying it is devaluing a gift given to us. “Suicide is the 11th leading

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay Euthanasia Should Not Be Legalized

846 words - 3 pages assisted suicide, whatever you want to call it, it should not be legalized.      People should live their lives for as long as long as it is worth living.  As long as someone can still have experiences and communicate with others, they should go on living. Someone may have six months to live and decides to end their life rematurely, saying that they are going to die anyway, why bother with waiting.  It is the same with

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legalized?

1212 words - 5 pages Should be legalized for physician to let assist terminally ill patients with suicide if he/she or family members request for it? In any case, either the patient or family members ask for it, we must look at many other reasons why legalizing assisted suicide is a wrong to the public. Therefore, it is extremely important to focus on the wrong doing that we are attempting to allow physicians commit. If physician assisted suicide legalized and made

Physician Assisted Suicide Should Be Legalized

1847 words - 7 pages Angela Gao March, 2005physician assisted suicide should be legalizedPhysician assisted suicide (PAS) refers to a practice in which the physician assist a patient to end his or her own life, in a painless or minimally painful way, for merciful reasons (encyclopedia.laborlawtalk.com). Its main purpose is to end patients' suffering. PAS is an intentional termination of life to the terminally ill patients and carried out with physicians' help such