"The French Revolution Was A Radical Political Revolution With Conservative Social Consequences". Do You Agree? Why?

1721 words - 7 pages

The French Revolution was indeed a radical political revolution which forged our modern liberal views; however the revolution also had many drastic and lasting social changes. The revolution created, as Peter McPhee states, "Twenty-five years of political upheaval and division {leaving} a legacy of memories, both bitter and sweet, and of conflicting ideologies which has lasted until our own time" and these political ideas ranged from communism to democracy and constitutional monarchy. Not only was the revolution radical in its political theories and debates but also in its social changes from overturning the noblesse d'oblige to liberating slaves and searching for equality between the sexes. This argument corresponds with the Maximalist line of thought, subscribed to by historians such as Albert Soboul, who give emphasis to the power of the French Revolution at creating a social paradigm in France and the world. However the minimalist line of thought, supported by Francois Furet contests this idea and suggests that much stayed the same throughout and after the revolution, leading to the recreation of the total supremacy of Napoleon. The revolution was not beneficial to every party who witnessed its passing, it did leave many already suffering classes in an even worse state; however it also created many social equalities, and urged the people to fill their desires in finding their freedom. There can be no doubt that the French revolution had many political transformations, however the social changes were far from conservative as the revolution battled for a radical social upheaval that was unprecedented.The French Revolution was a very politically active process which created a standard of political practice and theory which is not only discussed today, but is also very contentious. The use of propaganda throughout the revolution and the extent to which it was used is testament to exactly how radical the political side of revolution became. David mobilised entire schools of art and used them as propaganda machines for the Jacobins and all sorts of art was created in an attempt to legitimise and protect the revolutionary ideals . Not only was art a major aspect of revolutionary change but also pamphlets and newspapers were an essential aspect, perhaps the most famous example being Sieyes' "What is the Third Estate?" to which he answered nothing yet it was everything. This powerful idea that the bourgeoisie and the peasants, all members of the third estate, were the most important ambit of power within France, was clearly a basis for the theorising of a democracy. This idea of democracy and a politically active 'nation' created such a vast and powerful ideological overhaul that, as McPhee puts it succinctly, created a "rich seed bed of ideologies ranging from communism to authoritarian royalism." The political debates, elections and political rights gave the people of France a strong sense of unity and political freedom. The Jacobins themselves...

Find Another Essay On "The French Revolution was a radical political revolution with conservative social consequences". Do you agree? Why?

The French Revolution Q&A Essay

1289 words - 5 pages . What the French Revolutionaries did was get rid of all that opposed the Revolution or even questioned them by marking them as traitors and then sending them to prison, and then executing them with a new invention, the guillotine. This made the whole situation very hypocritical, which meant that the Revolutionaries had pretty much done what they wanted to stop, cruel punishment and unfair laws. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, Marat’s

Radical Revolution Creates a Base Essay

768 words - 4 pages , the most radical change to take place in the United States. During the revolution, America defeated one of the most powerful armies and achieved its first colonial victory. The French were considered “more important than the gods” (Ellis 8). Once America had overpowered the French army and navy other nations wanted to do the same. The United States was looked up to as powerful and fearless. Others wanted to follow in our footsteps. Therefore

To what extent do you agree that it was defeat in the war which was the real factor of the Russian revolution ?

632 words - 3 pages be dissolved by the Tsar. His conservative visions were not accepted among the society particularly by the middle classes who saw the incompetence of the government and wanted the creation of a representative government.Summarising, the author thinks that the First World War was the main and very significant factor of the fall of the Romanov monarchy. Badly commanded and backwarded army was unable to fight well with better equipped enemy. The

Why the French Revolution Took Place

844 words - 4 pages The French Revolution was a period in history of France covering the years 1789-1799, in which the monarchy was overthrown by the people that were dissatisfied with how the king and queen was running the country. According to The War Times Journal, “The era itself can be split into two periods; The French Revolution, and the Napoleonic Empire. The Revolution and ensuing republic saw the toppling of the old French monarchy and its replacement by

Analysis of the Political and Social Consequences for Iran of the 1979 Revolution

1123 words - 4 pages little freedom of speech against the government and the Revolution had not allowed new freedom to the people. The 1979 revolution brought not only a radical religious leader and theocratic style of government but it also brought with it good and bad consequences that Khomeini would have to deal with, as all the previous leaders had to do. The political and social consequences are numerous but other consequences like economic areas were brought about, this included how to deal with the oil revenues and other issues such as how to supply fresh water to rural areas and what to do with the previously owned ‘sovereign land’

This paper compares the American Revolution with the French Revolution

744 words - 3 pages "Give me Liberty or Give me Death," shouted Patrick Henry, one of the most important men from the American Revolution. He left a remarkable impact on American history. Similarly, the French Revolution had the same underlying principles of freedom and equality though it was fought on the opposite side of the world. The American and French Revolution both fought against a tyrannical government which mistreated the people of the country. These

The American Revolution Was a Real Revolution

829 words - 3 pages troops began to take place. Not everyone favored the revolutionary movement; this was especially true in areas of mixed cultures and in those that were untouched by the war. The citizens of the middle colonies were especially unenthusiastic about the revolution. Among those that did support a change, not everyone that joined the movement favored violence. Quakers and members of other religions, as well as many merchants from the middle

The French Revolution

2071 words - 8 pages overnight” (36). It is outrageous to believe that change would occur with a flick of the switch and if one was to look at the bigger picture, France would finally bloom into a glorious nation of social, economic and political justice. Albeit there was madness in the French Revolution there was method in’t and quite possibly a pinch of luck. Works Cited Andres, David. "Interpreting the French Revolution." Teaching History 150 (2013): 28-29

the french revolution

1218 words - 5 pages taxes. The Estates General was divided into three smaller estates. The First Estate of the Clergy, the Second Estate of the Nobility, and the Third Estate who represented everyone else outside of the clergy and the nobility. As seen in Document Two, the diagram illiterates the three estates and the land each held during the Old Regime, which was the political and social system prior to the French Revolution. Although the diagram portrays the

The French Revolution

2445 words - 10 pages ). In one document the feudal system is abolished. This means that there is no longer is law making a distinction social class for men. You may have had this in other countries as compared to other things that came out of the revolution but internally this was huge. Peasants now enjoyed basic rights others had. Kropotkin says that they can now sufficiently eat and openly speak their mind (Kropotkin). These are basic, fundamental rights. The French

The French Revolution

764 words - 3 pages would later get these. Another reason was that the old regime was ineffective and it abused its power. The immediate causes of the French Revolution were that the Estate-General had to convene. Increasing political pressure and being faced with the total collapse of its finances, the Old Regime began to unravel. Almost immediately tempers arose regarding voting procedures in the upcoming Estates-General. In its last meeting, voting had been

Similar Essays

The Radical Period Of The French Revolution

1024 words - 4 pages only a matter of months before the moderate stage of social and political reform was transformed into a radical phase of barbaric and violent force. In their quest for freedom, equality and fraternity, the leaders of the Jacobins inadvertently turned the revolution into an oligarchic dictatorship that threatened to destroy all that was achieved in the previous two years of insurrection. The revolution took a sharp turn on August 9th

The American Revolution As A Conservative Movement

815 words - 3 pages you were on and what year you are talking about.Those things determine what the definition of conservative and radical is at the time. TheArticles of Confederation were very conservative because, at this time,anything that proposed anything other than a weak central goverenment was consideredradical, such as the constitution which we presently live under. In our currenttime, even the constitution is seen as pretty conservative though, mostly

Was Napoleon A Betrayer Of The French Revolution?

1164 words - 5 pages betrayer of the Revolution. He seized power for himself, which contradicted the goals of the Revolution, for the people wanted to do away with aristocratic figures. An order of precedence was also reintroduced within France, which created nobility and mimicked a return to the political system that previously reigned over France. Lower class peasants weren't looked after under this system of rules, which is what many of the revolutionaries

More Than A Radical Revolution Essay

906 words - 4 pages Revolution Wood argues that the revolution actually began in the 1760’s and continue into the early 19th century as the country experienced a social transformation where people changed their habits and united rather that attempting to overthrow each other. He argues that the American Revolution was far beyond conservative. Wood describes how in order for our country to prosper we must do the impossible and separate our government from the