The Origins Of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory And Practice During The French Revolution And Beyond

1577 words - 6 pages

There are different attitudes towards politics

The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond

J.L Talmon

The author, Talmon, states that there are different democracy attitudes towards politics. The liberal approach assumes politics to reach through a matter of trial and error a state of ideal harmony, and the totalitarian approach is based upon the assumption of a unique and exclusive truth in politics (messianism). Political messianism recognizes only one level of existence, the political. It treats all human thoughts and actions as having a social significance.

It is a fact both schools underlie the value of liberty. Though, the totalitarian school believes liberty is a collective purpose, while the liberal school finds the essence of freedom in spontaneity and the absence of coercion.

From the same basis of the formation of liberal democracy (the French Revolution in the eighteen century), was born what Talmon called the "Totalitarian Democracy". Talmon refers to the existing paradox of freedom of totalitarian democracy in the sense of the difficulties of reconciling freedom with the extreme forms of popular sovereignty. Therefore, the idea of an absolute purpose quickly comes into the problems of totalitarian democracy.

Totalitarian democracy is an integral part of Western tradition in the 18th century after French Revolution. It brings about a new idea, which the past conditions should be replaced by deliberately planned uniform patterns. It was a result of the decline of the traditional order in Europe. For the first time, there was homogeneous society, where no different levels of social life or membership of a class and citizenship were present. Standard judgement was expressed in the idea of general good and the framework for all activity was the nation.

The 18th has some characteristics in social and political matter: the privacy of creative experience and feeling was to be swamped with one collective emotion; secular religion came face to face in a conflict between liberty and virtue and the result was great schism; totalitarian messianism hardened into exclusive doctrine, the social and economic based on ethical premises; the question of property which says that political messianism wasn't economic but ethical and political; physiocratic combination of absolutism in politics with the laissez-faire theory in economics; the postulate of salvation implied in the idea of the natural order; the principle of virtuous liberty to the passion for security; the ideology of the rising bourgeoisie was transformed into that of the proletariat.

The modern totalitarian democracy is a dictatorship based on ideology and the enthusiasm of the masses. It is the outcome of the synthesis between the 18th century idea of the natural order and the Rousseauist idea of popular fulfilment and self-expression.

During...

Find Another Essay On The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond

Maxilmilien Robespierre and his influence on the Reign of Terror during the French Revolution

1598 words - 6 pages Maxilmilien RobespierreLooking back at the history of the French Revolution, Maxilmilien Robespierre was definitely one of the most controversial figures. From one aspect, he was very virtuous and devoted to fighting for his people. However, judging from another point of view, Robespierre was a ruthless tyrant who took away the lives of thousands and thousands of people. So is Robespierre really a true dedicator to the Revolution or is he a

Document Analysis of Government and Justice During French Revolution

695 words - 3 pages Document A During the “Second French Revolution”, by implementing a new criminal justice system, radicals violated Cesare Beccaria’s Enlightenment principle that judicial law should ensure a trial while abiding by the natural rights of the accused. In Beccaria’s work On Crimes and Punishments, Beccaria articulated that it was the government’s duty to make laws and punishments that would aim to hamper crime. Beccaria opposed torture and capital

Reign of Terror was during the French Revolution

1810 words - 7 pages The immediate bloody aftermath , was a product of social, economic, and political forces. The spirit of idealism that gripped France during the early phases of the Revolution gave way to mass paranoia and extremism, culminating in Robespierre's cruel regime. In the beginning of the French Revolution, Enlightenment of the French Revolution, known as the Reign of Terrorphilosophy seemed like a panacea for societal woes. Prominent philosophers like

What made Rousseau's philosophy and David's paintings attractive during the French Revolution?

1309 words - 5 pages The causes of the French Revolution are so complicated that a debate still rages among historians regarding its origins, causes and results. In general, the real causes must lie with the increasing discontent various members of society had for the rigid social structure of the Ancient Regime. As it had been for centuries, French society was divided into three Estates or Orders. The First Estate consisted of the clergy and the Second Estate the

William Wordsworth: Romantic Poet during the French Revolution

1769 words - 7 pages WILLIAM WORDSWORTH INTRODUCTION William Wordsworth is a romantic poet who wrote during the French revolution. He is Regarded as one of the greatest English poets of his time. Wordsworth was the oldest among the Group of romantic poets of his time. Wordsworth wrote most of his poems before he was forty And in the rest of his life he spent revising it, among all his poems, tentern ABBEY and I WANDERED LONELY AS a Cloud€ which I will be

"The French Revolution was a radical political revolution with conservative social consequences". Do you agree? Why?

1721 words - 7 pages urged the people to fill their desires in finding their freedom. There can be no doubt that the French revolution had many political transformations, however the social changes were far from conservative as the revolution battled for a radical social upheaval that was unprecedented.The French Revolution was a very politically active process which created a standard of political practice and theory which is not only discussed today, but is also very

This essay talks about the French Revolution. It talks about the causes and effects of the it. It focuses a lot on the king of France during this time

1572 words - 6 pages The French RevolutionThe French Revolution is an important event history. The French Revolution brought about equality between the people of France. The Revolution's motto was "Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité. " This was French for "Liberty, Equality, and Brotherhood. Louis XVI was the ruler during the time of the revolution. He was also known as the "sun god" (The French Revolution). The king was crowned in 1774 at the age of

Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens. This essay reflects the stability of England versus France during the French Revolution

787 words - 3 pages In A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens, the author writes about the social problems in England and what is known today as the French Revolution. The novel is set in 1775, with a comparison of England and France. Both countries battle poverty, injustice, and violence due to the ruling authorities. The French people were tired of the social and economic inequalities enforced by the ruling monarchy. The aristocracy and clergy lived a life of

Analyse Madame Roland's letter regarding 'The Massacre at The Champ de Mars' during the French Revolution. State what further information you would need

893 words - 4 pages lie to a confidant, especially about such a public matter. However, she may also be inclined to exaggerate events to encourage sympathy for her political cause; using the term 'cut their brothers' throats' in reference to the National Guards. It is not a formal document so perhaps some of the facts have been misinterpreted. The letter, written one day after the event, leads us to question whether she is still shocked and perhaps this response is

Causes and Effects of the French Revolution

2250 words - 9 pages Revolution? The major cause of the French Revolution was the disputes between the different types of social classes in French society. The French Revolution of 1789-1799 was one of the most important events in the history of the world. The Revolution led to many changes in France, which at the time of the Revolution, was the most powerful state in Europe. The Revolution led to the development of new political forces such as democracy and

Causes and Reactions of The French Revolution

1388 words - 6 pages restrictions imposed by law." Clearly, the driving force behind the French revolution was the third estate's lust for social, economic, and political mobility, freedom and equality.The bourgeois were a new class of people that had capitalized on any chance to make money that had been presented to them. They were in some cases just as wealthy, if not wealthier, than their lords but they did not have the name. This familial lineage was the only thing

Similar Essays

Origins Of The French Revolution Essay

1066 words - 4 pages Long-term government financial chaos played a lead role in the cause of the French Revolution. This point is supported by William Doyle, in Origins of the French Revolution. Government debt and lack of available funding seriously deteriorated authority and credit, leading to extreme measures in taxation, thereby acting as a catalyst of the French Revolution.      Doyle makes his point by arguing that France was

Origins Of The French Revolution Essay

946 words - 4 pages There were 3 main causes of the French Revolution: Intellectual, Social and Political. Firstly, "Intellectual" causes of the revolution will be explained. Secondly, "Social" causes will be stated. Lastly, "Political" causes will be described.There were several intellectual causes of the revolution. The idea of liberty was one of the obvious ones. The enlightenment spread the scientific and philosophical thought throughout the 18th century. This

The Economic Origins Of The French Revolution

3280 words - 13 pages of being a European superpower in the eighteenth century and being focused on avenging previous losses, France entered the war openly in 1778, willing to fight regardless of political and economic consequences. (Origins of the French Revolution – Doyle 93-95) [FOMAT] With the signing of the Treaty of Paris in September 1783, the war formally ended and France regained many of the colonies it had lost in America, Africa and India after the Seven

The Economic Origins Of The French Revolution

2493 words - 10 pages monarchs, notably Kings Louis XIV to Louis XVI, felt, along with nobles who surrounded them, that they had the right to rule and act as they wished without the worry of repercussions. If the old regime failed to reform itself, this was in large measure the fault of Louis XIV, Louis XV, and Louis XVI, for they alone had the power, the authority, and the right to authorize necessary reforms. (Origins of the French Revolution – Doyle – pg. 53