The Rise Of Nationalism After The French Revolution

1485 words - 6 pages

After the end of French Revolution, as the empires slowly diminished, countries wished to become independent and develop nation-states. Possibly one of the first nationalists was Johann Gottlieb Fichte, who attempted to urge Germans to be individual from people of other nation-states. Many years later, more people became interested in nationalism, some in more positive ways than others. Ernest Renan questioned the definition of an actual nation, and what constituted a nation. However, not everyone agreed with nationalism. John Acton strongly opposed nationalism and maintained that its primary goal was not freedom. Unfortunately, the negative connotations and slight misinterpretation of the ...view middle of the document...

He continues to say, “[we must] throw away foreign contrivances,” (63). This particular notion is not only shocking, as most people were unaware of the early potential racism at the time, but it is also extremely illogical because to keep a country separate from the rest of the world is near impossible. A prime example would be trading with other countries. Each country must naturally depend on another, alliances must be formed and relationships must be made. Possibly unintentionally, it appears as though he was encouraging xenophobia, placing fear into the hearts of the public sphere.

A similar weakness of Fichte’s argument is that he unrightfully blames other countries, “It was only the deceit of foreign countries that dragged Germany into their own lawlessness and their own disputes; it was they who taught Germany the treacherous notion of the balance of power” (63). While blaming other countries, he refused to take responsibility for his own country, and additionally fortified peoples beliefs in fear of the outside and unknown as necessary for survival.

Mazzini’s primary belief in his essay “On Nationality” (1852) was that Europe needed to be reconstructed. He claimed, “Europe no longer possesses unity of faith, of mission, or of aim. Such unity is a necessity in the world,” (122). Like Fichte, Mazzini yearned for transformation. While Fichte was specific to Germany, Mazzini looked at a larger scale. Mazzini employed a call to action with this piece, as he perceived a problem and pleaded for an answer from Italy. He understood that once each individual nation was successfully created, all of Europe could be unified. However, his thoughts were similar to Fichte in the sense that he believed foreigners needed to be less involved in order for Italy to progress, “[Italians must] associate freely, without obstacles, without foreign domination, in order to elaborate and express their idea” (123). The “obstacles” that Mazzini referred were most likely people that did not express the same beliefs as other nationalists. This notion returns to the Fichte’s concept of unwanted foreign thinkers in Germany, and the preconceived perception that others will only do harm.

Mazzini’s thought of unification by altering the European map through nationalism was weak in itself. Although he was very clear in what he desired, that individual nations were created, he was unclear on how exactly he wished to change it or how he planned to go about the change. This idea is limiting and detrimental to his argument, as he does offer a suggestion but not a complete solution to the unification problem.

Each author had their own description of what true nationality was, and Renan attempted to describe the core foundations of a nation by starting off with naming what people of a nation have in common in What is a Nation? during 1882. Most importantly, he stated that all individuals in a nation have a “shared past”, whether it is glorious and heavenly or wretched and full...

Find Another Essay On The Rise of Nationalism After the French Revolution

Causes of the French Revolution Essay

906 words - 4 pages Revolution.Secondly, the unpopularity of the upper classes, the decline of the absolute monarch and the public hatred of Marie Antoinette were all major contributors to the beginning of the French Revolution. In many other parts of the world, the power of monarchs had been reduced in some way, such as England, or outright ignored, such as the United States. France began to see the rise of Enlightenment ideals, many of which called for

Causes of the French Revolution Essay

1210 words - 5 pages required France and the U.S. to work together on any peace agreement." After coming back to France, French military men had spread the word of the Americans, and their successful fight against both France and America's enemy: The British, and thought that if the Americans could fight a war for independence, so could the French. And so, the influence from the American Revolution contributed to the French Revolution.Last, but certainly not the

Causes of the French Revolution

1119 words - 5 pages revenue and comprised forty-nine percent of government expenditure (Taylor). In addition, France experienced bad weather and poor harvests during the year 1788 and, in turn, caused prices and unemployment to rise. This was followed by a harsh winter when many starved and this led to food riots and only increased public dissent towards the crown. The French Revolution was caused by inherent problems within France like the social inequality

Causes of the French Revolution - 1010 words

1010 words - 4 pages , revolutionary ideas were instilled within the people during the Enlightenment. Together, the financial condition of the government, the economic depression, and the Enlightenment ideas played a pivotal role in causing the French Revolution. In the late 1800s, the condition of the French government was pitiful, and corruption was everywhere. France was already in great debt after spending large sums of money on soldiers and weapons for the French and

Causes of the French Revolution - 993 words

993 words - 4 pages ). There were many political matters that were the root causes of the French Revolution. The two main political issues were inequality and France’s monarchy. After 175 years of monarchs not calling the Estates-General, Louis XVI does in early 1789 at Versailles. This was a result of his weakness under pressure for reform and his indecisive personality, which will cause a lot of the political problems leading up to the French Revolution. The

Causes of The French Revolution

526 words - 2 pages A revolution broke out in France in 1789 between the people of first and second Estates and the people of the Third Estate because the people of the Third Estate were treated incredibly unfair so they came together and took matters into their own hands. The three most important causes of the French Revolution were the bad economy and unfair taxes paid by the Third Estate, lack of voice and rights, and the idea of enlightenment and the

Causes of the French Revolution

2787 words - 11 pages would you feel if your voice wasn’t heard? The concept of inequality is not exclusive to the French Revolution. In fact, these variations are seen within our modern relationships, social structures, and political structures—a few of which are outlined above. In regards to the French Revolution, the misrepresentation felt among the Third Estate at the end of the 18th century was a factor of the outbreak of the Revolution. However, this sentiment of

The French Revolution of 1789

1957 words - 8 pages There is no doubt that the French Revolution has had a profound effect on the world. The cause or causes of it have been greatly disputed. Clearly the Revolution's primary cause was the presence of a weak monarchy and a lack of a stable system of government. France's absolute monarchy had many changes toward the end of the eighteenth century. King Louis XVI, in his attempts to consolidate his authority and lessen the power of the aristocrats

Origins Of The French Revolution

1066 words - 4 pages Long-term government financial chaos played a lead role in the cause of the French Revolution. This point is supported by William Doyle, in Origins of the French Revolution. Government debt and lack of available funding seriously deteriorated authority and credit, leading to extreme measures in taxation, thereby acting as a catalyst of the French Revolution.      Doyle makes his point by arguing that France was

Origins Of The French Revolution

946 words - 4 pages thoughts created the idea of liberty. Therefore, citizens became in the need of human rights/natural rights, the sovereignty of the citizens and equal rights for everybody under the law. Besides, the idea of the foundation of republic regarded as possible. Furthermore, "People can rebel against despotism", the idea appearing after the American Revolution was also a remarkable intellectual cause of the French Revolution.The social causes of the

Assessment of the French Revolution

1325 words - 5 pages Assessment of the French Revolution The radical phase of the French Revolution was the time when the Reign of Terror began. The radicalism (change in political and social condition of France) started with the emerged of republican (a system of no king) view among the people of France especially the Jacobins. Those who wanted republican became more active aiming to overthrow the king by finding faults on him

Similar Essays

The French Revolution And Nationalism Essay

934 words - 4 pages After the conflicts against Napoleon in 1815, the outlook of nationalism permeated throughout entire Germany by middle-class liberals and was influenced by the French revolution. Soon Bismarck unified the German states under Prussia. Nationalism encouraged the German people to stand against conservatives and when Germany was finally unified as the German Empire it was very much an authoritarian and a combatant state as well. This is a

Causes Of The French Revolution And How They Affected French Nationalism

1067 words - 4 pages success of the revolution caused a unified state to be reborn, and a new pandemic of nationalism to sweep France. A series of vital events destroying the absolute monarchy struck liberty, fraternity and brotherhood in French Nationalism. An era of enlightenment provided a ground for the bourgeoisie to rise in new ideas helping to develop the national assembly, and the constitution of the rights of man. This era also included a more physical

French Revolution And Nationalism Essay

1624 words - 7 pages strong sense of nationalism. The French Revolution was the beginning of not only French nationalism, but nationalism across Europe. Based off of Enlightenment thought, the passing of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen in 1789 was the beginning for this nationalistic movement. From the Declaration came the Reign of Terror, led by the National Convention. Enlightenment thought and the idea of equal rights were warped and mislead

Causes Of The French Revolution Essay 1927 Words

1927 words - 8 pages Causes of the French Revolution The French Revolution happened in France around the period 1789-92 (although these dates are disputed by historians), and resulted in the overthrow of the French monarchy and the Ancien Régime (the system of government). The monarchy in France had been established for many centuries, and the causes of the Revolution were deeply-rooted, including the problems with the Ancien Régime, the growth of nationalism