The Similarities And Differences Between The Sciences And The Arts As Intellectual Discipline

2354 words - 9 pages

During the course of this essay, I will attempt first to criticise science and scientists and show the arrogant assumptions that are made about science. I will then discuss the similarities between arts and sciences in the light of my criticisms, and finally look closely at the many differences between arts and sciences. There are several different criticisms that have been commonly levelled at science and scientists as a whole. I shall begin by attempting to identify these criticisms and identifying the reasoning behind each of them.The first of these criticisms is that science has been given similar status to a religion. It was commonly thought in the early days of science that science would eventually develop a theory for everything, thereby replacing religion through removing the ambiguous and the incomprehensible parts of life with which religion dealt. In many ways science has replaced religion in the 21st century, as it has become the object of faith and even devotion. A blind faith has been placed in the unquestionable correctness of science and scientific research. It was Emile Durkheim who first advanced the theory that given enough time, science would replace all traditional religions to be replaced by a formal, unquestionable religion based upon science. It is the arrogance of many scientists that leads us to believe that scientific theories are facts, and can be treated as 'truth' replacing religion by explaining the facts behind the creation and existence of the world. The problem with this belief that science is unquestionable fact and can be treated in a similar way to a religion is twofold. First, scientific theories are advanced through observation and experimentation, these theories can never be proved entirely correct since they are based only on certain observations, as the full facts can never be known, a theory can only be said to be correct in so far as it is correct from the observations made given the facts available. Secondly, science and religion can never be directly linked since they do not overlap in any shape or form. Science deals with the physical, religion with the insubstantial. In their very essence the two are diametrically opposed to one another and can't be compared. In short, science deals with the how, religion, the why. Although science attempts to understand the world around us, how it was created and how we and other creatures came to exist, it can never fully explain the automated human search for a higher being. There seems to be a desire within humans to believe in something larger and greater than that which is visible and physical, something science can never explain. For this reason, science can never replace religion, as it simply does not explain enough. It's explanations fall far short of what would be needed to satisfy human curiosity. Religion, in general, does a much better job of explaining what needs to be explained about human nature.However, Scientists in recent years have attempted to...

Find Another Essay On The similarities and differences between the sciences and the arts as intellectual discipline

Differences and Similarities Between the Holocaust and Cambodian Genocide

1006 words - 5 pages or material incentives (“Cambodia”). As you can see, these two Genocides were similar. In conclusion, these 2 genocides are similar in their ways of classification and the discrimination of the people affected. But, they were different in the areas by methods of extermination used and why they were killed. Misunderstanding can occur between people when they do not understand why they act as they do, causing them to distance themselves or even

Observing The Similarities and Differences Between Handmaid's Tale and Gattaca

1181 words - 5 pages Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, and the movie Gattaca reflect dystopian societies in their approach to human reproduction and social class. The illusion of utopia and dehumanization of individuals are present through both societies’ dependence on an elite group of males. Handmaid’s Tale and Gattaca, while sharing similarities between dystopian themes, challenge reproduction from two greatly opposing perspectives: science and religion

Similarities And Differences Between Ballads

686 words - 3 pages that chirped them over." As you can see so far, there are many differences in the way that these two songs, otherwise known as ballads, were written. That could be because of the big time gap in between, there was just a changed in the popular type of music. Or it could simply be that the authors had different tastes in their music.S. Foster repeated one line in the whole ballad, "Floating like a vapor on the soft summer air," that is what his

"To Kill a Mockingbird" Similarities and differences between the book and the movie

520 words - 2 pages To Kill a Mockingbird EssayTo Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, is one of the most famous novels in American literature. Consequently, it was inevitable that someone would make a film adaptation of the book. There are many similarities, as well as differences, between the movie and the book.There are many similarities between the movie and the novel versions of T.K.A.M., dealing with characters, plot, setting, and theme. One similarity is the

What are the major similarities and differences in the education system between Romania and UK

941 words - 4 pages What are the major similarities and differences in the education system between your own country and UK?Nowadays an important and discussed issue by all countries is the education system. In many countries from year to year politician try to make changes in order to improve it. However, it happens that instead of improve it the system become more complicated and corrupted. In some countries is believed that is better to learn everything by heart

Discuss the similarities and differences between the business case for equal opportunities and diversity?

1777 words - 7 pages The main focus of this essay is to discuss the similarities and differences between the business case for equal opportunities and diversity. In order to do this I will be defining the meaning of equal opportunities and diversity, the benefits and costs of equal opportunities and diversity, with examples of approaches UK organisations use towards equal opportunities and diversity. Finally I will be discussing the similarities and differences

What are some of the similarities and differences between the films Emma and Clueless?

1063 words - 4 pages they are not always right about making people together. Although there are many similarities in these two movies, there are many differences.One of the differences in these movies is the time settings. As a modern teenager, Cher lives in a wealthy modern house in a city in America. She also goes to a High School and she is well educated. Mr Horwitzz wants Cher to become a lawyer like him. "You mean to tell me that you argued your way from a C+ to A

Discuss the similarities and differences between ?new terrorism? and the more traditional model of ?old terrorism?

1906 words - 8 pages between the two faces of the terrorism. There is also the unity of targets as new terrorism borrows Western technology in order to destroy the West. “New” terrorism focuses its rage on old familiar aims – it is still a frontal attack on the institutions and principles of liberal democracy. Old and new terrorists consider themselves as those who are in possession of absolute truth and have the right and obligation to kill those who disagree or

The similarities and differences between the Federalist and Anti-Federalist papers

989 words - 4 pages were published between 1787 and 1788 although; the author’s names were kept a secret until 1818. Hamilton decided to sign the papers “Publius” to keep his name anonymous. Hamilton was the first to publish an essay and soon picked Madison and Jay to assist him. To their surprise, the Federalist papers influenced many of the New York people to vote for having the constitution ratified. On the contrary, the Anti-Federalist papers did not agree

the similarities and differences between hershey's track and field and skate in school

822 words - 4 pages The Similarities and Differences between Hershey’s Track and Field and Skate in School “The main thing is that it’s nice to see these young people- 9 to 14 years old- take the opportunity to get more involved in their health and fitness. We need more kids to be active.”-Rafer Johnson. This quote can relate well to Hershey’s Track and Field and Skate in School because the main points for each programs are about offering children the

Similarities and Differences Between Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? And The Weakest Link

1894 words - 8 pages Similarities and Differences Between Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? And The Weakest Link There are both similarities and differences between the two quiz shoes, they both have the basic format of a quiz show, the entertain, excite and amuse us which is a very basic formula for any good television program, however, they are dissimilar in many other ways. The similarities between 'Millionaire' and 'Weakest Link' could be

Similar Essays

The Differences And Similarities Between Plays

759 words - 4 pages The Differences and Similarities Between Plays Plays express different plots, yet authors use similar writing methods to convey a particular point. For example, one play discusses serious matters, while another play has a comedic tone. However, both plays use physical movement to represent a character’s mood. Death Knocks, Fly, and Our Town are three very different plays with different themes yet these plays use a lot of similar writing styles

The Differences And Similarities Between The Movies "Emma" And "Clueless"

675 words - 3 pages Emma vs. CluelessEmma and Clueless, are two movies that illustrate Jane Austen's novel entitled "Emma". The stories illustrate the importance of self-development and personal growth by using the theme of social status and moral worth. The protagonists, Emma and Cher, are bound to transform from callow young adults to mentally and emotionally mature women, given their similar situations.The major difference between Emma and Clueless is the way

The Similarities And Differences Between Theravada And Vajrayana

690 words - 3 pages The Similarities and Differences between Theravada and Vajrayana Before we compare and contrast these two different sects of the same religion, we probably need to define the why first. There appears to quite a few different splinters of Buddhism, however they seem to all have the same goal, just a different way of achieving that goal. Why? I believe it all comes down to interpretation. Since Guatama Buddha did not have any written

Discuss The Similarities And Differences Between Prokaryote And Eukaryote Cells

756 words - 3 pages a bacterium (See Figure 1). The other class is the Eukaryotes which are the cells of plants and animals, and example is a palisade cell (See Figure 2). Both have similarities and differences in their functions and structures.Both Prokaryote and Eukaryote cells consist of Cell wall, (however this is not present in animal cells) - this is made of Peptidoglycan (though the plant cell is made of cellulose microfibrils embedded in a layer of calcium