Who Is Helping Who? Essay

1039 words - 5 pages

Most of the western world has participated in some sort of imperialism, America included. The idea of imperialism makes sense to us because we have lived in a culture that has benefited from the artifacts of imperialist actions. However, what if the tables were turned? Instead of our country performing the seizing of land that is not ours, we are residents of a land that has had an unwelcome occupier take over the country. Most people would not take so kindly to such intervention. Most Americans realize the pillage of the Native American’s land as one of the biggest blemishes on our nation’s history. America is still paying the price for the wrongdoing to Native Americans in the form of ...view middle of the document...

Means refutes the idea that Europeans will learn to be respectful of other people and resources. The fact that Means has this opinion of Europeans is not surprising; the Americans were not known for adhering to treaties with Native Americans during westward expansion. One can see how easy it is to see the Europeans as selfish, knifing, and superior. The fact that Europeans are unable to listen to the Native Americans is important today in Karzai’s interview with the Washington Post.
While the war in Afghanistan has mentally, physically, and fiscally drained the United States, it has done even more to the country and people of Afghanistan, which has to live the war on a daily basis. Originally, the war was founded on just causes to seek out Al Qaeda members responsible for planning and carrying out terrorist attacks. However, because of the character of war, it was difficult to avoid all civilian casualties. Karzai saw his people dying and Americans potentially doing the wrong thing and was led to the conclusion that America was in Afghanistan for personal interests, not to rebuild the country. Karzai’s grievances come from lack of focus on the Taliban in Pakistan and illegal holding of prisoners who may not be guilty. President Karzai is feeling the same range of emotions that Means and the millions of Native Americans before him felt as the Americans took over a land that they were not welcome in. Karzai clearly disdains civilian casualties. Because of these casualties, relations with the United States have suffered. While still undesirable, causalities would have been tolerated if they were for the good of Afghanistan. However, Karzai believes “the war was ‘for the U.S. security and for the Western interest’” (Sieff). It is unrealistic to expect Afghans to die for U.S. interests much like it is unacceptable to ask Indians to live amongst toxic waste for an industrialized nation they are not a part of.
How does a group of people contest the undue influence of...

Find Another Essay On Who is helping who?

Who is Dr. Seuss? Essay

2207 words - 9 pages children's literature as Dr. Seuss. His imaginative characters, vivid illustrations, and catchy rhymes are easily recognizable to anyone who grew up reading his stories. Although most Americans are familiar with his books, many do not know much about his personal life. For starters Seuss is not his real name, his full name is Theodor Seuss Geisel. He started using the pseudonym, Dr.Seuss, for two reasons. The first reason why he used Dr. as his

Who Is Worthy? Essay

841 words - 4 pages , and is one to conform, then he or she is more entitled than he or she who is not. In Sacred Hearts, these subjects are investigated further in a different environment than most are used to. What exactly makes someone feminine or masculine? Femininity is a strong theme throughout Sacred Hearts, since the novel takes place in an all-female environment without really a masculine influence except for the priest, who is rarely at the convent, Santa

Who is My Neighbor?

2373 words - 10 pages My interactions with Jim left me with a number of questions that I continue to struggle with to this day. What does hospitality look like for those who profess to be Christians? Should Christians be trying to work harder towards better relationships with the other and those who believe differently than us? Is pluralism a plausible concept? What is my role as a pastor in leading the congregation in a time of Joys and concerns? As a pastor, how do

Who is the Author

1048 words - 5 pages there are exceptions but even if a book from a male author is successfully written and accepted by most of the women, it cannot be successful as a book from a female author. On the other hand, there are a lot of books that were written by female authors who later were found out to be males with fake female names. Authors use pennames either to conceal their identity or to write in categories that not specifically related with their own gender. Their

Who is Pill Gates?

1565 words - 7 pages : Who is Pill Gates? Some have heard of his name, some often confuse him to that tech guy who owns that big computer company or something. A lot people are wondering and are just scratching their heads saying and asking “who is this guy?” Who is Pill Gates? Well your guess is as good as the next guy. Go through all the search engines that you want, nothing even close will come up. Just a few articles that really don’t say much about him, some of it

Who Is Mark Twain?

1896 words - 8 pages . Visited McDowell’s Cave, the site that evidently became Jackson’s Island in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and McDougal’s Cave in The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. During the summer, Clemens would visit his uncle’s farm, near Florida, Mo. Here he played adventures with his cousins and attentively listened to stories told by the slave Uncle Daniel (Chicago Tribune) It is said that this is who became the model for Jim in Huckleberry Finn. His adventurous

Who is Holden?

874 words - 4 pages Who is Holden? The Catcher in the Rye is a very short coming of age story and the main character Holden Caulfield is trying to discover his identity while still emerging into adulthood. Holden describes himself as “the catcher in the rye” to catch the children falling off a cliff. The cliff represents adulthood and Holden wants the kids to keep their innocence. I believe this shows in Holden’s love for his little sister, Phoebe. His brother, who

who is to blame

909 words - 4 pages Who Is To Blame In the play Macbeth, written by William Shakespeare there is many people to blame for the downfall of Macbeth. There is an argument that there are more individuals at fault then just Macbeth. Though Macbeth was the one who followed through with all the decisions, it clearly descripts in the play that Lady Macbeth and the witches play major roles that helps lead up to Macbeths downfall. It shows that Macbeth and Lady Macbeth have

Who is King Arthur

872 words - 4 pages "Heroes aren't born, they're made" (MegaMind 2010). This quote is the perfect way to describe King Arthur. The stories of King Arthur have been passed down for centuries. He is a huge figure it literature and his stories have impacted many people. What if that is it? What if it is all just stories. History has provided us with much evidence that he is real. We also have a lot of counter evidence as we'll. So, who exactly was King Arthur and is

Who is Ishmael?

802 words - 4 pages it is understandable why Ishmael initiates his travels but Ishmael still leaves his readers with many unanswered questions, the most pressing of which being; who is Ishmael? “Call me Ishmael” (Melville 18), one of the most recognizable opening lines in literature, introduces one of the most interesting narrators in literature. What makes this sentence so recognizable is that Ishmael, the narrator, tells you exactly what he wants you to know

Who is Melchizedek?

1251 words - 5 pages In Genesis 14:18, Melchizedek is introduced as the king of Salem and priest of God Most High (El Elyon). During the return home from war with the enemies of Sodom and prior to his meeting with the king of Sodom, Abram has an encounter with Melchizedek. During this encounter, Melchizedek brings out bread and wine and then proceeds to bless Abram. After being blessed, Abram gives Melchizedek a tenth of the spoils of the battle. Who was

Similar Essays

On Our Own: Why We Who Struggle To Live With Diabetes Could Use A Helping Hand By Sarah Sklaroff

1998 words - 8 pages lifestyle has led to countless life threatening diseases. Of the numerous health problems that Americans’ are faced with today, diabetes remains to plague the nation by destroying the quality of life. In the Narrative Matters section of Health Affairs, Sara Sklaroff’s published article “On Our Own: Why We Who Struggle To Live With Diabetes Could Use A Helping Hand” describes a system that burdens people for having diabetes, rather than taking

Who Is The Inspector? Essay

1332 words - 6 pages Who is the inspector? In this following essay I will discuss who the inspector is and his role in the story. At first appears as a regular police inspector who is however rude and out of line but by the end of the play everything changes. Throughout the play he interrogates the Birlings and the Birlings for a crime they didn't even know they committed. However it is more likely that he is a ghost or a paranormal being or perhaps the voice of the

Who Is Kim? Essay

790 words - 3 pages Who Is Kim, What Is Kim?By birth Kim is a white, Irish boy, Kimball O'Hara, whose father was a soldier in an Irish regiment. But, as we see in Chapter 1, he has grown up, as an orphan on the streets of Lahore, 'a poor white of the very poorest', looked after by a half-cast woman, probably a prostitute; 'she smoked opium and pretended to keep a second-hand furniture shop by the square where the cheap cabs wait'. With his skin 'burned black as any

Who Is Joe? Essay

907 words - 4 pages The army is a great organization, but some people have a different opinion. I've been in the army for 17 years and though I haven't enjoyed every minute of it, I wouldn't change it for anything else. The people who serve in the army are very unique. They endure things most people would rather not and do it for reasons others can't understand. Some do it for the love of their country while others do it for the glory. For me, I do it for the love